Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Magnum Opus
Erestor
2004-01-31 . chapter 5
I suppose this was the end? It was a good one. I liked the way Lindir was the person who wrote 'Gil-Galad was an Elven King' and I also enjoyed the brief appearence of my favorite hobbit, Sam.
Itarille
2004-01-26 . chapter 4
Very interesting still. You write so well. I can't wait to see where the rest of this is going.
Erestor
2004-01-26 . chapter 4
Poor Lindir. I hope he does go back to Imladris soon. I liked this chapter, particularly this line: 'Have you ever known parting to be joyful?'
Hellga
2004-01-18 . chapter 3
First, a nitpick. Lambi Casarinvë is "Languages of the Dwarves". "Language of the Dwarves" would be Lambë Casarinva.
Now I can say that I think it was a very interesting idea to use objects in this way to illustrate connection between Elves. And of course I am honored to have a part of my poem included in a good fic like this one.
Erestor
2004-01-17 . chapter 3
I thought that was what he was seeing! You have shown how the Elves would react to the terrible news very well.
Erestor
2004-01-16 . chapter 2
Poor Lindir. He has grown up quite a bit since some of your earlier stories, but he still remains the same. This is another interesting plot, and enjoyable so far.
Erestor
2004-01-16 . chapter 1
Very good start to another promising story.
Itarille
2004-01-05 . chapter 1
Very interesting so far. I can't wait to see the next chapters.
Tinuviel-luthien
2004-01-04 . chapter 1
Excellent writting. I can't wait to see the next chapter.
Return to Top