 dogbertcarroll 2005-08-06 . chapter 1Needs some editing, but a good start. |
 ranger5 2004-06-04 . chapter 1Like this one too. Like I said if you want a pre-reader just let me know ... my e-mail is in my profile.
If you'd like a look at my writing check out Forever the Tomboy -- that's my R/SM crossover--it's a little different but I kinda like it (g) |
 hentairoses 2004-01-07 . chapter 1 a great start for a crossover and can;t wait for the update, but what Ranma going to do when the fiancee bigrade finds out he left to go find another woman. |
 Gopu 2004-01-07 . chapter 1 Really like to read some more. So please keep up the good work. |
 The DCG 2004-01-06 . chapter 1Good start, To bad ya took up half the damn page with that song. |
 nea 2004-01-06 . chapter 1 I like the idea you have for this story, but I think you might want to back up a little and go into some detail about the similar dreams that Ranma and Ryoga had or have them tell someone what happened in their dreams. Also, give us a little background on the relationship between Ranma and his 'Suna-chan' (I'm assuming to mean Setsuna). I hope these comments will be of some help to you. I really hope you continue this story, and I look forward to reading more! |
 Jason 2004-01-06 . chapter 1 The basic idea is so, so.
The execution is iffy. This is mainly because your grammer is in desperate need of work.
You used a lot of words in the wrong spots, or in the wrong ways.
The execution seems to indicate that English is not your primary language. If this is true, get someone who's a lot better at it to proof read for you. |
 Ryo-Wolf 2004-01-06 . chapter 1Not bad. Especially for your first fic. A lot better than my first, I can tell you that much. I did see a few problems though.
1. The whole song and dance routine at the beginning would be better off being removed.
2. I'm pretty sure Ryoga's name means "Good Fang" but I could be wrong.
3. A few grammar mistakes, but nothing too horrifying.
Another than that, good job. Keep it up. |
 Lanara Bolina 2004-01-06 . chapter 1very very good story. write more soon. |