Yet another one so sad. But this was also truly beautiful. Wonderful.

Your write really well, capturing emotions and characters beautifully. This story touched me deeply, it is so sad and bittersweet.

How terribly bittersweet. I'm crying. Beautiful story, as all of yours are.
-- R.C.

Why do you do this to me~?!?!?!?!?! *smeagol's howl*
oh my gosh... the emotions radiating through the fic is... indescribable... I just can't put them into words. I felt great pain... It just... stabbed my heart *weep* 'tis indeed, great and pure love. yet it's so suffering...
I'm not really into angst fic, yet i can't deny this... irresistable to me. although i hope i would get to read more happy ending ones like things unspoken or what so ever... this one brings me to my tears... *weep, yet again*
beatifully written as ever! I need not explain you the whole progress again, nay? ^^

Oh, you really write so well...; I loved the tragedy of their love and the way you portrayed it. You did so well in their speaking voices too (it disturbs me when the characters are written saying very modern phrases--kind of destroys the whole mood). This story was perfect for its premise, but now I need to go read, "Slap of Mortality", to cheer me up with the idea that these two can actually end up happily together.

This was an absolutely fantastic and touching story. Im actually not ashamed to admit that you made me tear up. You are a very talented writer and I can't wait to read more of your stories.

Excellent work. Lately, it's been really nice to read slash stories that aren't offensive or degrading to Tolkien's work, such as this story.
It's very well-written, and the characters aren't too OOC, and the story is quite possible in canon, which is always a treat.
Good work. I encourage you to keep writing. You're good at it.
Kudos,
Kel

i'm always so sad when i hear bout Gimli and Legolas leaving ME. coz it really is the end of the fellowship. good story by the way!
~FST

beautifully written. it touched my heart of it's sadness and beauty of the love that you subtly yet evidently portrayed.