 EstellaB 2006-07-26 . chapter 1*sniffles*
Oh that's so sweet! I mean I loved the other two ficlets as well but this one... I had tears in my eyes! |
 Live Fast Die Never 2005-02-21 . chapter 1OMG I'm surprised I didn't burst into tears after that. It was so sad, but so wonderful. |
 Katherine Burnett 2004-03-27 . chapter 1OMG! OMG! This was so touching. I loved it. It was so sad and heart warming. *Tear* |
 Lua under water 2004-03-23 . chapter 1"Look Diamond...a puppy.."
so SWEET!I really liked this story. i loved the way you managed to capture the hobbits love and sincerity. the story really carried feeling. thanx for writing it. |
 GoGoTorturegirlYeah 2004-01-19 . chapter 1omg u got me into puddles of tears reading that! >_< *runs for the next box of kleenex*... that was really nice... i love the mini-Pippin and mini-Diamond...so adorable...! do make more fics like this!! |
 Haya Madison 2004-01-19 . chapter 1*cries* This is unspeakably sad. But it's so good! |
 Psychogizmo 2004-01-18 . chapter 1Oh my god! That last line...*sobs* That was so sad and cute! I loved it! |
 Daisy Brambleburr 2004-01-18 . chapter 1Very nice fic. It could have worked if you'd have extended and used chapters, but the shorter way is just as good.
Just one gripe really, you seem to let Americanisms creep into your work. For instance, Pippin says 'Ew, mommy!' whereas I think it would be more fitting for him to say 'Ew, mother!' or even just 'mother!' Little things like changing the word 'yell' to 'shout' can make the general tone seem much more hobbitish.
Also, it's 'Bye' not 'by', as far as I know.
But good work! The ending was very sad. I've written a Diamond/Pippin fic that has them as childhood friends too, but I don't think I'll ever put it up here. I like the way you've charcterised her. :)
Daisy |
 Cyn 2004-01-18 . chapter 1 Very sweet. Great job. |
 Frodo Liv3s 2004-01-17 . chapter 1Holy crap. That made me CRY. I RARELY cry when I read fics, VERY rarely, but yours...Wow. That was really good...Can I put this on my favourites list? Cuz I'm going to.
'Look, Diamond... a puppy...' *sniffle* *sniffle* *SOB*
*more sniffling* You should have tissues along with this...So good...
*sniffle* Thank you.
--Shamon |
 florgurl 2004-01-17 . chapter 1How sweet! The end nealy brought me to tears.
~*~flor~*~ |