Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Help
Reviews For: Harry Potter and the Secrets of the Sorcerers - Reviews: Page 1 of 2
Sir-Tannin 2005-07-22 . chapter 2
Next chapter?
cmar 2005-04-25 . chapter 2
I really enjoyed this. You certainly have created the atmosphere and style of the books, and even the little bits of humor. Very lively dialog, everyone in character, a couple of distinctive and interesting OCs, a pleasure to read. Nice job on the puzzles, too.

You're probably aware of this, but you slipped into present tense sometimes - the only real technical complaint I have.

I see this hasn't been updated in a while - a long while - but I hope to see more.
gamegeek2 2004-11-07 . chapter 2
Very good and long story you've got here; please update soon!

And how can anyone not be a H/G & R/Hr fan?!
StarBella 2004-10-09 . chapter 2
Wow! This is really, really good! Bravo :)

For the first time I've actually found a fiction that the characters are in character. God, I can't even do that! Plus these are nice, long chapters (I hate it when people take forever to update then it's only about 5,0,0 words).

You've got an interesting concept as well, with the sorcerer and stuff. Again, much better than I could ever do *shrugs*.

I only have three small bits of criticism (not that I'm flaming or anything but I hate it when I make a mistake and prefer to have it pointed out so I can improve).

1. This is all written in past tense, but there are some bits that are written in present tense.

e.g.
The two share a look, knowing that the other is thinking the same thing.

2. When Harry is talking to Locke about the previous DADA teachers you spelt 'Gilderoy' as 'Golderoy'.

3. Most of the time the characters have good normal conversation but there are some parts when it seems a little stiff and scripted.

That's all, but again I have to stress that I LIKE THIS STORY!

*Looks pleadingly* Update? Please?
Jill 2004-09-01 . chapter 1
Mr.Lupin? I thought they just called him Lupin
Goldilocks31890 2004-08-11 . chapter 1
this is cool. i love the jesse plunk guy and his house elf... teeheehee. bet hermione did too! post more soon??
da90schic 2004-08-02 . chapter 1
cool story!
Queen of dusk 2004-07-23 . chapter 1
I like it alot.
Inqflow 2004-06-29 . chapter 2
Please continue the story! I like the idea of Harry having a relitive. And this Plunk guy... He's weird, cool, slightly funny, and powerful all in one. Reminds me of Dumbledore...Anyway, add more soon!
Nimbirosa 2004-05-16 . chapter 2
I love your story, please update soon!
Tanydwr 2004-05-12 . chapter 2
Great story. I love the long chapters, and the ideas - especially a Dursley being a Muggle-born wizard!
One thing, wouldn't Harry have certain aspects of the Muggle-born logic, being Muggle-raised, or was he so isolated from everyone, he never really had a chance?
Are any of them Sorcerers? It would be quite interesting for Harry, Neville and Locke to *all* be Sorcerers, don't you think? Harry has the destiny, Neville has the knowledge of them, and Locke has the brains.
Anyway, keep up the good work, and update soon.
Lol, Tanydwr
Shreve 2004-05-08 . chapter 2
good story. I like the rubix cubes. Can't wait to see more of Dier. I have a few plans for a story similar, just never wrote. Now that I have found yours, I won't have too. lol
Looking forward to your next update. Happy writing.
EbonyFirePhoenix 2004-05-06 . chapter 2
are you sure that wasn't a pun on tommy boy's name?
Tempest Dragon 2004-05-01 . chapter 2
I like Plunk's personality. Keep writing and update soon!
Headmaster Cromwell 2004-05-01 . chapter 1
Hello!

I am Headmaster William Cromwell, the headmaster of the Salem Institute of Magical Crafts. Salem is an online roleplaying community based off of the world J.K. Rowling created in her Harry Potter books. Students accepted into Salem, which is an American magical school that is much like Hogwarts, are able to attend magical classes, play Quidditch, and have adventures.

I read some of your story on Fanfiction.net, and thus would like to cordially invite you to look over Salem. If you are interested in joining, please submit an application, we would love to have you there.

The address to Salem is:

http://w.geocities.com/headmaster_cromwell/

And the address to the student application is:

http://geocities.com/headmaster_cromwell//globedetermining.html

I hope to hear from you soon,

Cheers!

Headmaster Willam Cromwell
Return to Top