Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: The Old Souls - Reviews: Page 1 of 3

BrokenSkye
2007-03-22
ch 10,
abuseUm!
Um - objection!
You can't leave it there!
Just when he was going back to save Lee/Archie - back to the days of Hornblower!

Please, please, please update!
K
2006-03-19
ch 10, anon.
abuseThis is a good story. Please update it soon.
Mady Bay
2006-01-02
ch 10,
abuseHey, Cyndi... any new chapters for the New Year?? My beta fingers are itching...
angry penguin
2005-08-28
ch 10,
abuseGreat story. I was afraid that it was left as unfinished.
Michele
2005-08-27
ch 10, anon.
abuseYippee! It's continuing! Glad to read two more chapters -- and can't wait to read the rest! An interesting way to cross two of my fave series.
adafrog
2005-08-27
ch 10,
abuseInteresting story. Well written, though.
Thanks.
sue
2005-08-27
ch 10, anon.
abuseHey Slea! Val and I are glad to see a sign you still exist. We've wondered what's been happening with you lately. Glad to see your updating your BSG story again. I love it.
Apollo's Lady
2005-08-27
ch 10,
abuseWOW!... I hadn't thought to see more... It had seemed so long! THANK YOU! I love the Hornblower tie in... I'm a big fan of both!
Mady Bay
2005-06-23
ch 9,
abuseHey, Slea - you gonna update this soon? I'm realling missing my beta job. Send me some chapters!!
Darlian
2005-04-23
ch 9,
abuseWow, different and thought provoking. Very interesting! Michael is a good character, especially since he is willing to sacrifice himself to save Lee. So Lee will guide the fleet to earth?
Rover
2005-02-27
ch 1, anon.
abuseI would really like to see this story continued and it should be moved into the new BSG section. :-))
BSG2003rocks
2005-01-19
ch 9,
abuseLove the story. Please right more soon. I wanna know if Michael is successful. I can't wait to find out what happens.
Cestari
2004-12-17
ch 3, anon.
abuse"Welcome to Purgatory..." I take it you've seen Horatio Hornblower?^^
Becki
2004-09-12
ch 7,
abuseOoh, nice. Had me a little worried there too. And what's happening with the Adama's? It's so worrying and sad. Are they going to be okay?
Erinya
2004-08-29
ch 7, anon.
abuseit started out nice enough and could be a great story. However, it does not live up to expectations; while the first chapters seemed intriguing, the rest was ...doubtfull to say the least.

One question - why take some wonderful, 3-dimensional characters and ruin them? Mythical powers, mythical artifacts, strange personal backgrounds - there is no better way to Mary Sue a canon character than by supplying them with those strange and really way-out-of-line powers.

I'd recommand watching the miniseries again. It's dark, it's gritty - play around with physical and psychic demands, the strain on everyone, the exhaust and you'll make a wonderfull story.

You certainly have the ability, it shows in the way you write. Try to strive for more than this.
Return to Top