oh wow, I just found your story, and I hope you continue it!

This has to be one of the best fics I've ever read. You take the characters from the movie and expand them so much, make the readers feel their pain. It's amazing :3 I really hope you do update soon, as it's been about a year since chapter 4 was released :[

Really powerful chapter. Not as much Logan/Rogue as I would have liked, but you more than made up for it by showing us more about Rogue herself. You just answered every question I've ever had about her and what happened to her, and I'm astounded by your skill. Please, please continue this story soon! I want to see how you'll explain Rogue's reactions afterwards.

Loved the way this chapter ended. It just shows how devoted Rogue is to Logan, and how much he really did for her. You've given us an argument for all those who say she's too young for him. Thanks!

At first i was disappointed because you switched to Rogue's POV, but this was just awesome. You have such great insights into their minds. Can't wait for more!

Really really enjoyed this. I loved the insights you had and the way it all seems to flow so smoothly together. This is an incredible story!

"Then again, she hadn’t had much of a chance to show that to Logan himself. The train had jerked to a stop only a moment later, bits of metal twisting everywhere and making her wonder if commitment-phobic Logan’s promise to stay with her had somehow triggered Armageddon."
bwahahahahaha

Really great chapter, even for you. I liked Rogue's perspective on the events of Liberty Island. The movie just glossed over it, but I always thought something had to be going on in her head. At the very least I wondered what she was thinking when she woke up, since she now had Magneto in her head, too. You did a great job with it.

I liked the "I skewered you. We're even, kid" comment. Very funny, and very Logan. Nice job.

I liked the switch to Rogue's POV. Really interesting takes on the movie.

Really liked this. Logan and Rogue are awesome together.

Hey, this story is brilliant can not wait to read more, im loving the extra emotion and feelings behind actions that the movie just skimmed the surface on. This must have taken a long time to write though but im glad you did!! im eagerly awaiting your next installment.

Melissa

more than awesome chapter! I really loved what you did with Rogue's thoughts during this part of the movie. I can't wait for the next part!

really awesome chapter. Loved the descriptions.

another really great chappie. I liked how you jumped to Rogue's POV. It's like reading two stories, but in a good way.