Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Gaining a Son - Page 1 of 4
Mih Black
2009-07-27 . chapter 2
it's one of the greatest fanfictions i've ever read *-* addictive
mandita
2009-03-23 . chapter 2
That is so sweet!! I love James's parents!!
keatlin
2008-09-22 . chapter 2
Great story! Love the interaction all around.
hypercell
2008-08-02 . chapter 1
The last line was very cute. I loved it so much!
Lycanrai Moraine
2008-02-19 . chapter 2
what? is it over? where's the rest? make the rest^^ please? make sirius and remus together^^
emuroo
2008-01-20 . chapter 2
This story was really cute, it does make an interesting point about James. Even if you don't agree that Sirius and/or Remus are gay (I happen to think so), James made some pretty interesting friend choices- a werewolf, a person thrown out of his family, and Peter, who is his own story.
emuroo
2008-01-20 . chapter 1
This is really great! I really like the way that you portray James' dad.
albe-chan
2007-12-02 . chapter 2
aw...yay
it was so angsty and good
lovely
Ame Mika'zuki
2007-07-30 . chapter 2
That is such a cliff hanger! ..if you'll still continue this, which you won't. ^^; Still, it was a great story... I like how you let Henry Potter deal with Sirius' issues. :3
Smiley0531
2007-07-22 . chapter 2
That's it?? That's the end?? But... but... but... *cries* that had the makings of an AMAZING story! Couldn't you extend it? To say, just the end of the summer, even? or heck, all school year? I would absolutely LOVE you for it. You have a great writing style--very unique. You portray both the Mauraders AND James' parents very well. Most plots only develop good characterization for James and Sirius OR his parents. And throwing in Remus' 'furry little problem' at the end was genius... I just wish I knew more. Sorry, I know this story is a bit old, but could you ressurect it for a desperate fan? or possibly develop a sequel?? I'd be your best friend... *bats eyelashes*
At any rate... keep writing!
~Smiley0531
xxanglophilexx
2007-07-19 . chapter 2
Wow. This was amazingly written. I loved how it was through Henry's POV--very unique idea. It was also nice how they dealt with Sirius and Remus's issues the way they did. I liked how Henry was a bit off-set about Sirius being gay, but wasn't revolted about it, and how they handled Remus being a werewolf so well. I love how they thought of Sirius as their son. Just really, really well written. It was absolutely fantastic.
Cuban Sombrero Gal
2007-07-19 . chapter 1
Lol, this is brilliant.

*cringes at the thought of moving pictures*

Great work

Cuba
MinervaEvenstar
2007-07-19 . chapter 2
Oh darn, I wanted to see what happened when he gave James and Sirius The Talk. Well, it was still a great story!
MinervaEvenstar
2007-07-19 . chapter 1
"Unfortunately, their second child had never arrived. Or, perhaps he had. Just a few years later than they’d expected him." That's so sweet how they think of Sirius! I like how realistic James' parents' reactions to Sirius' secret were. There are lots of fics about when Sirius runs away to James' house, but I've never seen one from a parent's perspective, so I give you massive points for originality.
Marauder's Mad
2007-02-27 . chapter 2
a very good story, original and well written !
I like the way you picture James's parents !
Return to Top