 christinajoyyy 2007-09-21 . chapter 1i loved this so much. thank you |
 foreverliesl28 2006-11-07 . chapter 1wow!! really top-notch story! i'm a die-hard tsom fan (as can be inferred by my penname) and i've always thought that the laendler was like the most romantic dance ever! i loved this story!! |
 Genevievey 2006-04-25 . chapter 1Aww, this is great, Rory! I'm sorry I didn't find it before (it's Julie_Rox from the forum, btw) I love what you've done with this, both with the title, and the way Maria is reminiscing about her parents as she dances. This combined with her newfound love for the Captain makes the Laendler something very central and important in her life. Thanks for sharing! |
 ImSoReddie 2006-03-14 . chapter 1Brilliant! Thanks so much for a great fic, I loved it so much, ti was just what goes through your head when you watch her, and when you pretend to be her, or maybe that's just me? *Shrugs* hum, anyway, thanks again, write more soon!
xxStellaxx |
 Teacher on Toast 2005-12-13 . chapter 1I like what you've put about Maria's father - it's a nice little story. I especially like the repetition of 'What a lovely couple you make', but I would have made its effect on Maria different. I get the impression that Elsa would be saying it spitefully, as she loves the Captain herself. Surely Maria would have detected this and felt uncomfortable by it.
But one thing that really hit me hard was that the reason why Maria is so upset about being in love with Captain Von Trapp is because she is a Nun, and Nuns aren't supposed to be in love. If she hadn't danced with Captain Von Trapp and fallen in love, Brigitta wouldn't have pointed it out to her, and Maria wouldn't have become so scared as to run back to the Convent without saying goodbye. Maria later expresses to Mother Abbess her concerns to keep the vows of "poverty, obedience and - chastity". She confides that "I was there on God's errand. To have asked for the Captain's love would have been wrong."
I don't intend to flame, but a lot of this plot-wise didn't sit right with me, although I respect that the actual writing is in itself very good. |
 McAdamsFan12 2004-09-21 . chapter 1aww...that was soo sweet! |
 Nicole 2004-06-24 . chapter 1 That was nice, indeed. I loved the way you gave us a hint of Maria's mom and dad. It seems like such a nice memory to remember. *tear* I wish I could cry now, that was nice. Keep up the good work, your gonna make kleenex sales go up, lolz. |
 katie 2004-05-27 . chapter 1 ok, so i haven't read this story, but i bet it's super-good. i remember when there were only 4 stories in this section. memories, memories. one of my stories is called my favorite things, or something like that. |
 Shannah 2004-04-20 . chapter 1This was a wonderful story. The way you interpreted Maria's feelings was splendid. Keep on smilin' ;) |
 paige 2004-03-29 . chapter 1 ha! i finally read it. i must say its an awesome story. |
 Quillusion 2004-03-21 . chapter 1You know, as far as I'm concerned this dance scene is the single most romantic moment in all of film. Not a word is spoken during the critical moments, there are no cues aside from body language and facial expression- and even that is fairly circumspect, given that neither knew what the other was thinking- and yet, BAM! You get it! I enjoyed reading this and imagining Maria and her father dancing. Nicely done!
Q |
 Ilandra (too lazy to sign in) 2004-03-13 . chapter 1 What a sweet little story! I loved your take on Maria as a child, and like the idea that the dance has special significance for her. I thought the scene between littleMaria and her father was very well written, and quite touching. I look forward to more such things from you! |
 Lizzy127 2004-03-09 . chapter 1Aww... lovely job!! This was such a sweet story! You're a wonderful writer... and I'm looking forward to more stories from you in the future! |
 RiskaSG 2004-03-09 . chapter 1That's a really cute little story. However I wondered what might have happened with Maria's parents - cause in "Something Good" she sings "Perhaps I had a wicked childhood, perhaps I had a miserable youth, etc."... *Sigh*
Sorry for pointing up to that, LOL, just my thoughts on your Fic - which is really grand;-) |
 ClassicTVGrl607080 2004-03-08 . chapter 1Good Story. Please continue with your writing! |