Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: The Disturbing Adventures of Rúmil and Kaye - Page 1 of 3
Kaye Thorn
2008-08-28 . chapter 11
Um nono, I just said I try to listen to scholars. In fact I'm trying to study it myself... XP I'd say you're not the one listening. The fact is I'm TRYING. And I'm not going to take it at face value when you say you're a "scholar". They tend to help people, not try to bash heads in.
Kaye Thorn
2008-08-28 . chapter 2
Reply to "nono":
Not to sound rude, I don't believe you're more qualified than the people on elvish dot org or Ardalambion. The only sources better than those sites are likely Tolkien himself.

This is supposed to be a lighthearted story. Stop taking it so seriously.
Alianora in the Rain
2008-03-23 . chapter 6
Thank you very much. I look forward to reading new chapters that you will hopefully post.
:)
Alianora in the Rain
2008-03-22 . chapter 11
What happened to ch. 1-6?
I wanted to read them, but they're gone!
I hope they come back soon, and I really like this story from what I've read. Garbage disposal stuffed with trash? Ouch! Ours is clogged, but I don't know why.
Kaye Thorn
2008-03-20 . chapter 1
In reply to "Slayer3".

I'm glad you don't think this is just another mary sue fanfiction. The main point of this story is to go against that stereotype. I have absolutely no intention of turning this into some dropped into our world typical mary sue romance. Or having any such factors present. I partially mean to show how difficult daily life really is, and if something like this did happen, it'd be incredibly strange and hard to deal with. With a fun twist, because I have an insatiably bad sense of humor (otherwise it might be pointless too).
To help go against the usual fanfiction, I did another strange thing. Let me straighten something out that's easily missed. Rúmil is from Valinor, not Lórien. I am not using Haldir's brother or any relation to him. The two characters have no connection whatsoever, other than their name. My Rúmil is also Noldorin, not Silvan. He invented the Elven writing system way back before the Elves returned to Middle-Earth. He was a loremaster, not a warrior. I found his character in the Book of Lost Tales (1&2). This is one pair of the few dozen books I have read by Tolkien (and his son) or on him by other authors.

I found the Elvish on very accredited websites that are run by academically driven people like the or Ardalambion. These are widely known for their in depth detail and accuracy. In actuality, I should've done Quenya instead of Sindarin. I did not have access to a resource for that language at the time I started this story. It would make more sense for Rúmil to speak this, rather than Sindarin. Though it is hypothetically possible, I may go back and change it. For fun I did that Mary Sue Litmus test, and scored very very low. There is no way any of my characters fit the abhorrent standard.
Thanks for reading.
Manwathiel Stormbuddy
2008-03-06 . chapter 10
very funny and amusing.. and highly insane!!
Slayer3
2008-03-04 . chapter 2
Firstly Im glad thats not just another stupid idiotic Mary Sue fic where in which Mary Sue and her fwiends at sleepover/random night where parental gauradians are missing/dont exist/dont fit in the plot cause they would ruin teh hawt secks! that would go on..*gags...One small tip well two..Second, neither of you should be able to understand each other...Elves esspeically this one who happens to be Haldirs brother, speak Sindiarin depending the on age, I believe King Thengel in the first age banned Quenya, cause well it was outdated...What you and he are speaking is called Grevlish..an RP(role playing) langauge a couple fans made up, for they game called The Grey Company. It has nothing to do with Tolkien or anything...For an authenitic site go Navear Laliaths author page and use her site Real Evlish. Its got everything anyone could possibly want to know about elves..Three please run your character through a Mary Sue Litmus test, yes I know you want to avoid Sues..So all you have to do is put LOTR Mary Sue Litmus test into any search engine, yahoo! or msn, or google and itll give a bunch of links to different sites. Take the tests and see how you score...Fourthly for the love of the Valar and all that is holy, please for Erus sake dont turn poor Rumil into some teenage boy...k? Hes a several thousand year old elf, whos a warrior, one of the Galaddrim for Manwes sake, hes faster, stronger and much wiser than a 16 year old girl..Please keep him that way...good? good:-P

Happy writing:-P


Slayer,the completly obsessed fangirl
IMSGEST and Sue Squad member
darklink231
2005-10-16 . chapter 9
hey! this is a pretty funny story! i hope you don't kill the elf... and just to make sure... *snatches rumil and shoves him in my closet*
Celeblas, Silver Leaf
2005-01-09 . chapter 9
UPDATE NOW! it is to good to be left just at this chapter!! UPDATE ASAP!
Elvin BlueEyes
2004-12-26 . chapter 1
ANY DAY NOW THAT YOU CAN FINISH THIS STORY. HOW LONG HAS IT BEEN? ALMOST WHAT A GOOD YEAR ALMOST! THIS IS A VERY INTERESTING STORY!

plus i read this thing when it first came out but i wasn't a member yet.

Elvin BlueEyes
Elvin BlueEyes
2004-10-01 . chapter 9
I really like this story. Keep going on it. Rumil is doing a great job.

Elvin BlueEyes
Devil-Angel
2004-08-30 . chapter 9
Hahaha, that was really funny!! Update soon PLZ!!
xkuroxshinobix
2004-08-20 . chapter 9
thats a great story!! theres not many pplz that write rumil or orophin stories. keep up da good work tho! hope to read more! see ya =D
THECheeseTurkey
2004-08-16 . chapter 2
LOL! Coolness! i love stories like this.

You are lucky, the Valar was nice to you, they GAVE you an elf. I had to take mine, it wasn't easy eaither... ^_^! hehehe

Legolas: Yeah, she just randomly appears out of nowhere, ties me up and takes me off to a castle made of cheese!

Me: It is NOT made of cheese! Hehe read my story called 'Fan Girls United' and u will get it. I think you will like it!
THECheeseTurkey
2004-08-16 . chapter 1
Cool! LOL! I love stories like this where girls 'Elfknap' lotr elves and force them to live with them. Reminds me of my own situation...lol
Return to Top