Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Help
Reviews For: Things Fall Apart - Reviews: Page 1 of 38
Ne'ith5 2007-12-21 . chapter 71
Yes Caranlass is a Marysue, she displays extraordinary characteristics and you have given no explanation why she is capable of such feats.

However, I still like the character. Excellent story by the way.
sazza-da-vampire 2007-04-20 . chapter 77
i am in love with your story! i read all 77 chaps in three days, and you HAVE to post the epilogue! i wanna know what happens!! i especially loved the bit where the young elves shave their heads - the looks on the other elves faces! a pity that Elrond couldn't see it. (or did he? i can't remember)
farflung 2006-07-31 . chapter 77
I was just getting ready to write out this review last nite and we had a huge power surge and my computer went dead. Really dead. I was so panicked. DH said it had been a long time since he had updated so he was busily planning to buy all kinds of bits and pieces, he builds his own computers. Finally after a few hours of tinkering while I sat and tried to act as if I was holding up well it got back to almost usual. What a scare. He kept saying get on the lap top, he has one and so does DD. It just isn't the same.

I am glad that you are having such a good time. We did when we were in NY. We got to visit friends, got see Thoroughly Modern Millie, lots of tours and museums and shopping. I fully intend to go again when my knees are fixed.

OK - Last chapter. For some strange reason I thought I had to review almost the whole tale but it was just the last chapter. I don't feel quite so overwhelmed.

It is hard to keep Legolas from roaming isn't it? He is just a curious kind of elf. He didn't get that from his father. At least the king thinks he has him cornered for some time to come with his honey-do list. Gandalf knows better though. The calm before the storm.

That was a nice elven birth. I thought the 'brave infant who would be balky under the curcumstances was so cute.' Having the king be happy over Laurelasse was a nice touch.

So things came back together again for a happy ending. And I get to start reading and reviewing the quest from Legolas' viewpoint. This should be good.

Thanx for a wild and wooly tale
Joee1 2005-08-01 . chapter 77
Wow, what a great story. It was nice to see Thranduil give permission for the young parents to name their daughter Laurelasse. It really shows how much he's grown since the beginning for your stories.

I do, however, have two requests for stories. Of course I'm not expecting that you'll write them right away, but you could save them for a rainy day. The first one you've already heard before, but I thought since there was what I am interpreting as an open-ended request for suggestions for new stories, I thought I would mention it again, lol. It involves an elfing Anomen and a certain set of stairs, a cave, and a really big spider. My other request is just a little inside look at how Legolas felt during the quest right after Gandlaf fell in Moria. I think you could do a really nice job with that one.

Anyway, once again, brilliant story =)
Joee1 2005-08-01 . chapter 76
Aww, another sweet chapter. I just love Thranduil now. Haha, I love Glorfindel's comment (and Galadriel's too) at the end, I never tire of hearing (or rather, reading) it.
Joee1 2005-08-01 . chapter 75
Aww, what a sweet chapter. I love how much Erestor had come to care for Marta. Great job =)
Joee1 2005-08-01 . chapter 74
Well I'm glad that Legolas is geting better. I like the part about Mithrandir being desirous to cast a spell upon someone. Terrific chapter =)
Joee1 2005-08-01 . chapter 73
Something tells me Thranduil is not going to be too happy. First he will recieve the news that Legolas was not married and has been injured and now this. I hope the twins do not have much trouble findiing Aragorn. Good job =)
Joee1 2005-08-01 . chapter 72
Yikes! Remind me never to ** off Haldir, lol. I hope he finds Mithrandir soon, it sounds like Legolas really needs his help (and here I though that he was just trying to get rid of Nana so he could sneak out of the room somehow, lol). Great chapter =)
Joee1 2005-08-01 . chapter 71
That would be annoying, seeing the future but not having the ability to really do anything about it. Nice chapter =)
Joee1 2005-08-01 . chapter 70
Haha, poor orcs, they can't do anything right. Well I'm glad that they managed to resuce Tathar. Nice chapter =)
Joee1 2005-08-01 . chapter 69
Haha, I like Nana's arguement about child birth. How is a man ever supposed to respond to that?

That must have been so embarassing for Haldir to be caught like that. Good chapter =)
Joee1 2005-08-01 . chapter 68
Oh, I hope Tathar survives. You wouldn't kill him, would you?

Is it wrong that part of me wishes that Legolas had been caught? Lol. Although in his present condition I doubt he could have survived, it still would have made for some painfull fun, especially if Saruman had gotten his hands on him, lol. Nice job =)
Joee1 2005-08-01 . chapter 67
Ooh, the mention of hiccoughs reminds me of a very funny story I read a long time ago. It's just known as 'Untitled' and is by Skyfire2 ( but it's hilarious, you should read it.

I hope Tathar and Caranlass are all right; and Legolas too. Even though I know he will live, I can't help but feel worried for him, lol. I can't even imagine what Nana must be feeling. Great chapter =)
Joee1 2005-08-01 . chapter 66
Lol, I forgot about Grima, son of Grima, son of Grima, and I still wonder where they actually find their wives. Honestly, who would want to mate with them? Nice chapter =)
Return to Top