Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: A Queen
Constant Distraction
2005-09-17 . chapter 1
Wow. You portrayed grief very powerful in a short piece. Great work!
Nera Black
2005-06-20 . chapter 1
Short, but deliciously angsty all the same. I like it very much!
Voldie on Varsity Track
2005-06-18 . chapter 1
Wow... angsty to the max! Good job! ;)

And thanks for your review... and yes, I did know that. It's just that Faramir was still speaking, but I couldn't lump everything into a huge paragraph.

Thanks, though, and please keep writing! ;)

-Christie
AJ-Sparrow
2005-05-05 . chapter 1
I love strong women characters, and a Queen who is fighting to stay strong and not to cry is amazing. Again, like i said in the other review I did for your other story, I've never seen the Lord of the Rings, but again, it didn't matter. You've taken this character and made her all your own by putting in the emotions. It's truly wonderful. Are you going to continue the story?
Maiden of the Dawn
2004-07-23 . chapter 1
Hey, EverVengeful, I really enjoyed this story. You did a wonderful job catching Arwen's emotions and thoughts at the funeral. One thing I really like about your story is it has a unique spin to it. I have yet to read another Arwen story where she regrets having loved him. Very original; in a field where there's not much originality, this is like a breath of fresh air. :D I also like your word descriptions, like this one: "...it feels as if my heart is being scooped out with a rusty knife and strung on a gibbet..." and this: "I am one of the Elf-kind, doomed and blessed to live forever, to never love a mortal. Cursed to live out all the Ages of the world without a blemish."
There is a little bit of angst here, but I believe with a little more work, and some more added thoughts of Arwen's, you would have a good amount of angst going. You could even write another short chapter with some more of Arwen's thoughts if you wanted to make this longer.

I'm sorry I didn't get a chance to write a review sooner. I've been really busy with my new job. Thanks so much for your kind review of my story. I love getting reviews! I'm looking forward to reading more of your work, EverVengeful.
Atanvarne
2004-06-25 . chapter 1
I almost cried. That is so sweet! You are such a great writer. I'm going straight to your other stories. This little beauty is going on the favourites list.
Reasonably crazy
2004-06-12 . chapter 1
Bright lil' ray o' sunshine, ain'tcha?

Good, though. Depressing, certainly, but good.
pandagrrl
2004-05-01 . chapter 1
not so sure it was angsty...but it definitely has emotion.
Jo Quinn Undomiel
2004-04-30 . chapter 1
Great job with this short thought-provoking story of Arwen's!
Ciel-Undomiel
2004-04-30 . chapter 1
i hope i get to be the first reviewer! wow this is good... poor Arwen... T_T
Evenstar Elanor
2004-04-30 . chapter 1
good. i like the "Queen does not cry" thing, except in joy. it really brought it all together. i like the ending "I am one of the Elf-kind, doomed and blessed to live forever..." one thing is that i don't think Arwen regretted choosing Aragorn that much. i mean, of cousre, she rued it when she felt the grief, but i think it wasn't as extreme as u put it. good tho!
Return to Top