 Tinorial Peredhil 2005-04-12 . chapter 1I got this from the MC awards page (I'm a tad bit slow on the uptake-- only a couple of months!) and now see why it was given an award! I loved it! Fantastic, fantastic, fantastic! I thought you were really going to kill those poor, poor, defenseless, fighing-for-the-good-of-Middle-Earth-- I'm sorry. Where was I? Ah yes. I thought you were going to kill them. Tricksy! But fantastic story! great! LOVED IT! |
 NaughtyNettie 2004-10-19 . chapter 1What a great story. Touched on several emotions and I loved the last two paragraphs. Well Done! |
 Deana 2004-07-25 . chapter 1You did a very good job with this! I answered Karri's challenge too; her and I decided to make it a challenge one night and I was so glad, because it was a fun scene to work with! Here's the link to mine if you want to read it: http://w.fanfiction.net/s/1805159/1/
Poor Legolas; how we torture him so, lol! |
 aronoiiel 2004-06-27 . chapter 1Kellen this was an amazing story. Plenty of angst and fluff beautifully woven together with an excellent writing style. I truly enjoyed this story. Thank you so much for sharing it. |
 tychen 2004-05-01 . chapter 1 Yup,enjoyed the ride no end.I totally and absolutely concur with Elrond,as a mother of three sons I 'would give nothing for a simpler life'.Though at times they may drive me to distaction and grey hair they are the most precious gift that I have ever received.So glad they all survived,even more glad that our local Orc problem is reasonably controlled.(Yes they do still roam the earth,you can see them in every cruel and mindless act around you,they're just harder to spot).Elrond and Thranduil's friendship came over as well as their son's.Feel free to write another anytime.I'll be waiting. |
 Jamesofme 2004-05-01 . chapter 1 I like Elrond's thoughts on this and thought you did a very interesting job. Ever feel bad for those boys though?
James |
 Rose 2004-04-30 . chapter 1 A good story which I enjoyed.Thank you. |
 amy 2004-04-30 . chapter 1 Wonderful. I loved Legolas' injuries and Elrond's introspection. Delightfully angsty. Can't wait to read "Faith." |
 lmw 2004-04-30 . chapter 1 i have spent the evening reading all your LotR stories. Very entertaining! Keep writing. |
 Gershwhen 2004-04-30 . chapter 1 A nice view in to Elrond. I do hope you consider writing more about him (and more in depth) in the future! |
 Karri 2004-04-30 . chapter 1Nicely done, Kellen. :-) Thanks! |