My favorite line is the first, but the rest of them follow closely. I really love this piece; poignant, and beautifully done, and utterly *right* for these two. I bow to your genius.

Your imagination is amazing. I am a Finrod fan and thought I knew him pretty well and I never imagined this converstion. BUT it is so right and is PERFECTLY in-character for both of them.
I am glad to find another Finrod fan and writer in this wilderness of Feanorians and Fingolfinians.
Not to sound cliche but I like your writing, I'm not very good a describing exactly what I like but your stories are a pleasure to read. Intensely captivating and so well written and flows so easily that I am transproted to the scene and loose myself in the story.

I think that both Gimli and Finrod Felagund like to sit together and talk about things they know so well. I am certain that Gimli is quite amased, sitting beside an Elf who his people were very fond of. I am also certain that Finrod likes to hear what became of his friends.

Why haven't I reviewed this yet? Ah, never too late, I hope. :) It always amazes me anew how you find different points of views. And the ease and familiarity between Gimli and Finrod just feels right. :)

Nicely done. So this is Gimli and . . . who, exactly? Finrod Felagund is my guess.

This is wonderful. The idea is unique and feels just so *right*, and the voice--perfect.

i like the use of quotes in the beginning, sets it up.. Felagund...

This is wonderful! The rhythm of the words and the flow...simply beautiful. Gimli's wonder is perfect. Everyone seems to dwell on the Elves point of view of a dwarf in Aman, but what of his, surrounded by the Eldar? *g* I think you've quite captured that here, and IMHO Tolkien's hope for the races to dwell with one another in understanding.