Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: But you gave up the sky - Page 1 of 2
SGWLESSIUT
2009-12-28 . chapter 1
This is well writen and it makes sense.
secilmis yazar
2008-11-15 . chapter 1
wow. that was quite clever!
t-214261asd
2008-06-23 . chapter 1
wow! I don't believe i've realized before how parallel the wizarding world of Harry Potter and Artemis's world with the People are. They have so much in common, and yet at the same time, so many differences! Excellent job, i loved how the two centaurs, stories, and backgrounds came together XD I now see why this won the Orion award!
FanOfFics
2008-01-19 . chapter 1
I really like this story! It's very well written and I could almost hear the charecters talking. This is a great crossover
Indecisive Mind
2005-05-04 . chapter 1
Oh! I LOVED the way to made a connection with Foaly and Firenze from Harry Potter! It was brilliant! (No, I'm not British. I'm actually Chinese. AND I'M PROUD OF IT!)
silverfingers
2005-03-11 . chapter 1
Wow-very serious and philisophical.A nice change.
Jouichirou
2004-09-03 . chapter 1
[laughing madly] HAHAHAHA! i always HAHAHA loved it HAHA when the silly HAHA centaurs HAHAHAHA go HAHAHA "mars is bright tonight" HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!! [wipes away tears of laughter] it always cracks me up, the way they say that. thanks for the laugh, this fic was great!! :)
wyldwych
2004-07-22 . chapter 1
I think this is really beautiful; I never would have thought of it myself. You should write a sequel, something that involves wizards and the People as well.
Yuka Sakura
2004-07-02 . chapter 1
nice story!! its a really unizue idea to add other characters from other stories in especially when they are they same "species"... do you get what i mean?? anyways, i've got a question... are you going to continue this story or not?
Socia Munsa
2004-06-11 . chapter 1
It's really good, but foaly was a bit OoC. He should have mentioned his technology or something.
little miss demosthenes
2004-06-07 . chapter 1
Arg. I owe you a review :: hugs :: because :: very, very evil grin ::

pulls out gun and points* get. that. limit. thing. to. work. or. you. die.

Nyways, just remember the six steps I told you to gain control of Microsoft and the world :: grin ::

The real reason is because I read one of your recent fics and didn't bother to hit the Go button and collect 200 dollars.

I have not read this before, but now I have! And I think it's a bit 'emotional' for you =P seeing you are USUALLY NONRESPONSIVE on msn. Nice job, though; I like the flow. Still, it's...dreamy. :: clap ::

*Evil green furry monsters come and raid her trash bin*

goddamn duck! :: whack ::

Oh, and good luck with getting into mensa. Did I tell you how sure I am that you are going to be there? Oh, and btw. I love this quote so much that I framed it and packed it into my stuff going to Massachusetts.

Why would one want to be a genius?
--Period of silence where black knight is avidly thinking--
JUST TYPE DON'T THINK.
It would be nice.

-Ppfftthhahahahahahahahahahahh :: sputter ::

Ehem.

I am offically spineless! Yae! Jellyfishes unite!

Cyah

ps> goddamn CSS scripting STILL isn't working! It's being a total **! [omg, la palabra '**' is like, so not PG]
edHuan
2004-06-06 . chapter 1
Can't really remember what i wanted to intended to wrote when i first read it but i think it sounds something like this:-
Ahm...i'll state to obvious first. It is wonderfully written, most excellent i might say (:P). a thought provoking fanfic giving us, i mean me, an insight of a might-have-been, refering to the crossover.

**Argh, scrap that. It's superb and i like it and im sorry it took so long for me to review it.
edHuan
2004-06-06 . chapter 1
Can't really remember what i wanted to intended to wrote when i first read it but i think it sounds something like this:-
Ahm...i'll state to obvious first. It is wonderfully written, most excellent i might say (:P). a thought provoking fanfic giving us, i mean me, an insight of a might-have-been, refering to the crossover.

**Argh, scrap that. It's superb and i like it and im sorry it took so long for me to review it.
Gilraen
2004-06-05 . chapter 1
No offense but, Foaly's a bit OC,he'd never go on about mars or "The open sky". But that's a REALLY neat idea, please continue this story!
The CheezHead
2004-06-05 . chapter 1
Wow, I liked it. A different type of AF/HP crossovers. I have to say it's the most original I've ever read. Kudos for you!
Return to Top