 RS 2005-08-10 . chapter 1 You have a knack for making me cry. Tis a bittersweet story. I love the way you wrote this. Very clever. All I can say is WOW! The way you go back and forth with the visions! AMAZING! PLEASE WRITE MORE.
RS |
 RedemptionOfHope 2005-07-08 . chapter 1Great fic |
 Valia-Elf 2004-06-13 . chapter 1wow. that is so good plz continue with it! Poor Celebrian, i know i wouldn't want to have to go through all of that. I like the way you described Arwen dancing with 'milord'and the repetive questions and answers of both Arwen and Celebrian. v.good!! |
 Constant Distraction 2004-06-08 . chapter 1Such a good story, definetly favorite list material. I love stories where Arwen's mother begins to see her daughter's fate. |
 Tinuviel Undomiel 2004-06-08 . chapter 1It seemed strange and sad to read through Celebrian's eyes. I have never really wondered about Arwen's mother. In my soon to be posted fanfics, Arwen's mother is dead. I feel sorry for her to learn that her daughter stayed on middle earth to die with her love, while she had been alone in the Undying lands. Its sad, but I think she would understand that Arwen made the right choice. I like your story a lot, it was sad yet meaningful. |
 Aragorn's Girl Arwen 2004-06-07 . chapter 1WOW! I loved this story it was so good! I almost cried! you are such a good write please keep up the good work!!
Arwen aka KItty |
 Gionareth 2004-06-07 . chapter 1 By the time I finished I was crying! So much beauty, so much detail... I could feel exactly how Celebrian felt. you are a trully gifted writter... |
 sielge 2004-06-07 . chapter 1 O, how beautiful is this story! Thank you for share it with us! |
 The Eighteenth Letter 2004-06-07 . chapter 1 This is wonderful. I like you portrayal of Celebrian and Arwen and the way you keep repeating and adding to Arwen's 'story'. This is an excellent fic. |