Wonderful scene. It works with the canon so well that it seems like a segment from Book 3 nixed due to length. :)

This was lovely. I love the idea that Ginny came to talk to Lupin as well.

That was a good story. It makes sense that Ginny would look to Lupin for help, and the little extra details--like the picture of Tonks and him knowing how its like to lose a friend--made it realistic.

Oh... the ending! THe ending! It's haunting!
Remus is all sweet and comforting and Ginny is adorable. Well done!

Fantastic. Perfect characterization. This was wonderful. Each detail lent itself to a larger story. Example: "Sirius himself, if Remus remembered correctly, was just out of the frame." Excellent.

Wow, I love it. That last line is genius.

Very clever idea, how Harry isn't the only one with really bad memories.

I think this is great piece. I enjoyed the characterisation greatly. I also loved your character comparisions between Lupin and Ginny. I think you tent to emphasise with italics more than you should, but besides that this was good.

Wow. I Hear Him Laughing is such an amazingly beautiful and well written piece of fanfiction. Thanks so much for writing it, FernWithy! Good luck with all of your fics :)

Love, Little Miss Mionie

Excellent! I´d never have thought of it. Great work on a really original piece. Keep it up!

I really loved this. Especially the plot, I wish I could think of ideas this great! I loved the end also, I dunno why I liked it so much it was just really good =]

Very nice, good job.

Wow, I'd never thought of Ginny's experiances and how dementors would affect her.. At the beginning of the story even, I was wondering what memories she had that a dementor would feed on.. At least, enough to merit true unease and such.. Loved the characters, Remus seemed spot-on, with his subtle humour and slight moments of uncertainty. That line 'You haven't bothered me so far. Were you planning on doing so?' was perfect. Loved that.

You make me despair of ever writing good fanfic.

That's a compliment, by the way. ;) I read several of your stories last night and decided I couldn't comment on all of them because they were that good--I just didn't have much of anything to say. I love what you've done with Lupin especially, though, and how you've shown his interactions with various people--Sirius and Tonks in particular. This one is really sweet too...I never thought about how the Dementors might affect other students, but I can imagine they would have. Wonderful fic.

Lovely. I just adore supportive!Remus. Ginny is so sweet in this aswell. I love how kind Remus was to her and the subtle hints about his secret.