Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: The East Gate - Page 1 of 26
asdfjkl;
2009-04-18 . chapter 19
wow. absolutely amazing--i loved it!

though i think you need to continue the story-it seems to me that these experiences would change how the rest of the quest goes. people learned things they didn't learn in the real story so they would react differently to dif situations.

anyway, i think you need to label this fic done and you'd get more people to read it.

loved it!

keep writing xD
Ducky'sgirl4ever
2008-03-09 . chapter 19
A great last chapter. I liked the bit where they all thought they were in Overheaven.
Ducky'sgirl4ever
2008-03-09 . chapter 18
Another great chapter. I liked the part where Frodo was singing that song again for Merry.
Ducky'sgirl4ever
2008-03-09 . chapter 17
What a great chapter. I almost fell out of my chair laughing when Pippin got sick from eating too much lembas, that was very well done.
Ducky'sgirl4ever
2008-03-09 . chapter 16
Another great chapter. I liked the part where Sam, Merry and Frodo were reunited.
Ducky'sgirl4ever
2008-03-09 . chapter 15
Another great chapter. I liked the part where Gimli was rmembering the farewell feast at Rivendell.
Ducky'sgirl4ever
2008-03-09 . chapter 14
Another great chapter. I liked the part where Merry asked what Legolas had done to bring him back and he told him about it. Another of my favorite parts was when Pippin had eaten nearly all the lembas.
Ducky'sgirl4ever
2008-03-09 . chapter 13
Another great chapter. I liked the part where Legolas was bringing Merry back.
Ducky'sgirl4ever
2008-03-09 . chapter 12
Another great chapter. i liked the part where Sam and Frodo were both taking care of each other and the part where Boromir was taking care of Pippin.
Ducky'sgirl4ever
2008-03-09 . chapter 11
Another great chapter. I liked the part where Aragorn was taking care of Sam and Frodo.
Ducky'sgirl4ever
2008-03-09 . chapter 10
Another great chapter. It will be intresting to see if Aragorn actually catches up to Gollum.
Ducky'sgirl4ever
2008-03-09 . chapter 9
another great chapter. I knew Gollum would catch up to them sooner or later. It will be intresting to see what happens with that storyline.
Ducky'sgirl4ever
2008-03-09 . chapter 6
Another great chapter. It's going to be intresting if Gollum ctahces up to them. My favorite part was when Boromir was comforting Pippin.
Ducky'sgirl4ever
2008-03-09 . chapter 5
Another great chapter. I liked the part where Merry thought he was with his grandma.
Ducky'sgirl4ever
2008-03-09 . chapter 4
Another great chapter. I enjoyed it all.
Return to Top