Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Between Him and Her - Page 1 of 2
Freederth
2007-04-17 . chapter 4
Momi, apple-chan made me cry! >o<
That wasn't fair xD
Well yeah, I really liked the fic, indeed it's a very beutiful one.
YEAH xD

Ok... not much more to say, If I continue takling, it would be a offense for such a good fic xD
da-mouse
2006-01-25 . chapter 4
WAH WAH WAH!

First of all. That. THAT. All that writing. One word to describe it. BEAUTIFUL. It's not good enough to describe it even. It MADE ME TEARY. IT MADE ME CRY. OKAY? I HOPE YOU ARE HAPPY WHY DID YOU KILL HER?!

...actually, I know why you did. And I know why it had to work out the way it did. I think this is the best resolution ever though. He wouldn't have been able to be together with Marco and I think that's the worst part of it - he loved him and HER but now she's dead, there's just no going about it anymore.

Okay I am not coherent. But I love the final part. I love how you're writing again. I love you like a lot even if you made my heart and head hurt and all teary and using a piece of tissue.

Your writing? Still as amazing as ever.

LOVE!
Sheo Darren
2006-01-23 . chapter 4
Sad. Very sad. Fitting, powerful, but sad. My heart feels so heavy now. I'm very sad.

Listening to Three Doors Down's "Here Without You" as I read it. Coincidence?

Goodbye, Jeanne. Sayonara solitia...

"I'm here without you, baby,
But you're still on my lonely mind.
I think about you, baby,
And I dream about you all the time.
I'm here without you, baby,
But you're still with me in my dreams.
And tonight, it's only you and me."

Kudos.
nezumi
2004-07-31 . chapter 3
*This is the sucker for angst speaking.*

I have been waiting for this, you know I have, with greatest anticipation and as usual, you never fail to deliver, mummy dearest. Jeanne's pain was so wonderfully written, and it's really sad how she cannot love Lyserg because of certain vows and promises she had made and never could go back on them.

Her selflessness is very suitable to this fic - for she has to give up as she cannot be with him. And even though it was literally killing her to give her blessings - she did it all the same for him.

Love at its noblest and yet it is a love loss.

Beautiful, beautiful piece of angst, mummy. I really felt sorry for Jeanne, your writing is no doubt, very powerful.

Can't wait for the resolution now! Although there's not going to be any more angst...right?

^^ + hugs
nezumi-chan
solbi
2004-07-26 . chapter 3
Is Jeanne-chan going to die? NO!
Pantsukon
2004-07-26 . chapter 3
aww poor Jeanne, it's so sad. So, it's cute and it's always good ^^ keep that work!
Sheo Darren
2004-07-26 . chapter 3
You're right. It was weird.



But it's a very well written story. Allowing my Jeanne-Lyserg bias free rein is bad, especially if the story deserves it.

Poor Jeanne-chan. I wish I could make it up to her somehow.

Jeanne: "How about posting your ManKin story, as you promised two weeks ago?"

Oh. Right. Sorry...

Great fic! I want to see how this ends (but it's sad, no Jeanne-Lyserg... )
Sheo Darren
2004-07-02 . chapter 2
Oh, my. Marco certainly is OOC. But it is a very quaint and entertaining story. Very beautiful, even with the hint of shounen-ai. (For some personal reason, the thought of Marco interested in someone else other than Jeanne and Meene and my own OC Rune kind of scares me.) But it's a good story, very good.
da-mouse
2004-06-30 . chapter 2
*glomps* UPDATED! Heh, much as I don't have a preference for this triangle you're writing, I still love to read it. ^^

Marco's OOC-ness...admittedly there's some sort of it [seeing how he was a total and complete ** in Mankin anime/manga] but I think I am liking this Marco more than the in-character one. Heh. I think that's a wonderful insight into Marco's thoughts, though. Great explanation of the relationship build-up between him and Lyserg. It made the relationship possible [cos Marco was always an ** to Lyserg]. Gah, didn't know that Marco could be so deep. ^^

The part about Jeanne is so sad though. She's pushing the one she /could/ love and who loves her away to another person. But I can see her pain because of reasons that she cannot overcome, so she wishes for Lyserg to be happy and believes that Marco could give it to him. Nice touch there. I like the conversation between Jeanne and Marco.

"...No matter what happens, I will find you, Lyserg. And I will take you home."
I like this bit a whole lot. It just gives so much hope and strength and one couldn't help wishing for a happy resolution. I just think the "going home" part is kinda sweet. ;)

Great update, mummy dearest! Now I can't wait to read Jeanne's part. I am a huge sucker for ANGST and you know it. Hehe.

=) and hugs,
Nezumi-chan
Pantsukon
2004-06-30 . chapter 2
You write really well =0, it's good!! I want to see the next chapter ^-^
da-mouse
2004-06-25 . chapter 1
*Hugs to Mummy Ringo*

You already knew what I thought about this story XD but me reviewing all the same. ^^

First off...let me say that this is REALLY a unique triangle to be tangled up in. ^^ Probably the first Marco/Lyserg/Jeanne fic ever published. The RP REALLY do give us great ideas. Hehehe.

And...wonderful wonderful writing as usual. I think the Lyserg angst is written most wonderfully. So sad and moving...how he loved her and yet, he knew that it could NEVER be, not between him and her. Great portrayal on that.

I like the established sort of rapport between Marco and Lyserg. It's a great point to make how some respect existed between them, and I like the overview of their relationship's evolution. Ah, we all know that Marco's not a meanie. He's actually a nice softie. ...right? (winces) But yeah, great take on Marco's reactions. It was subtle but yet bringing on the point most wonderfully. And the Lyserg/Marco hints in the same category as well: subtle but workable.

Me, for one, can't wait to see an update, even if I neither a Marco/Lyserg or Lyserg/Jeanne fan. Simply because a good Mankin fanfic is hard to find nowadays and I really hope for you to write write write! ^^

Lots of hugs,
nezumi-chan

P.S. Most powerful line in this chapter: - If this is my salvation, he thought bitterly, then I'd rather not be saved. - Wonderful. ^^
Pantsukon
2004-06-20 . chapter 1
...that's sad...but...I LOVE THAT PAIRING A MUCH! Write MORE fics like that X3
Summer Raindrop
2004-06-20 . chapter 1
Your right. It is wierd, just like you. I'm beginning to think your Leasurg/Jeanne obsessed!
Well, i hope you finish it so it won't be so pointless.
TheBeautyOfEternalSilence
2004-06-19 . chapter 1
*Wipes a tear*thats really sad and touching,write more soon please.
Lysberries
2004-06-19 . chapter 1
Yay, it's up! ^o^

Aww... This was really sad. I feel sorry for all three of them... Is Lys ever going to come back? I really want to know what happens between him and Marco now... and how he'll deal with his feelings for Jeanne.

Gah... You are SUCH a good writer. I still can't believe you'd dedicate something to Yomi-chan and I. *huggles* Please continue soon!
Return to Top