 suzy 2008-06-20 . chapter 1 Pretty cool fic, poor Severus though, but Severus' mum wasn't a Longbottom i think her last name was Prince. |
 Rynn 2007-06-21 . chapter 1Absolutely amazing! Quite funny it was read the ending and remember that Lily and James would get married later on...too bad for Snape. |
 Diminished Seventh 2005-05-27 . chapter 1This is very well-written. I don't think JKR meant James to be that bad, but you did it well and everything seemed in character, which I love! Cool title - I love that introductory Potions speech by Snape! |
 Rosmerta 2004-08-19 . chapter 1 Yay, new Rebecca J. Anderson!! I haven't checked your page in a long time, and now I'm glad I waited, because there are a couple of new fics to enjoy. This was a good one - well thought out, well written, and very logical. Only one thing - a break between the two scenes would help - I mean a row of asterisks or some such thing. It was a little confusing before I realized the second scene was some time later. ... And WHAT evil demon prompted the idea of a Snape-Longbottom connection?! Poor Neville, what a thought! ;D |
 MySite 2004-08-08 . chapter 1Pretty good fic |
 Lilithakaducky 2004-06-23 . chapter 1I liked the idea. Nicely written too. Congrats on that.
I tried to look up your link but couldn't access it. I'd love to see your theory. |
 HeavenStone 2004-06-23 . chapter 1The best line, I think, is "Still, if she ends up with Potter, he'll ruin her." So true. I'd really like to see more on this from Snape's POV. How heartbreaking for him, to watch Lily fall in love with such a prat. I hope Rowling takes this idea a little further in her future books and in the meantime I'm enjoying myself reading lovely little ficlets like this one. Really makes you want to slap James, doesn't it? --make him see he isn't all that great. Gryffindors. So overrated. |