 timme 2009-03-11 . chapter 2 finally. good mother. her people my foot, what about her son's family, ya know? good for her, and them. |
 Tatsumaki-sama 2007-02-14 . chapter 2So touching. I felt like crying when Estel ran back to Elrond. /"I could not take that light away from you now. And not from him, either."/ Awesome line by Gilraen. |
 Guardian Angel of Wolves 2006-04-07 . chapter 2My! This should come with a "bring-box-of-kleenex" warning! Well written |
 Dagnir Erynion 2004-12-15 . chapter 2Aww. *sniffles* That was sweet. :) |
 et-spiritus-sancti 2004-11-18 . chapter 2This was the cutest little story i just happened upon. You wrote Elrond perfectly and Gilraen is just how i've imagined. You have a beautiful writing style, so keep up the good work and good luck with future stories!!
~sancti~ |
 Aragornwriter 2004-10-04 . chapter 2Very strong story, Any. The way you've written Elrond and the way you've captured his emotions was very sharp. I felt like knocking some sense into Gilraen (good thing that wasn't necessary, lol). I loved it. A very good tale. |
 Catmint 2004-09-30 . chapter 2I'm sitting here with tears in my eyes. This is such a moving, emotional story and I absolutely love it. Incredibly powerful. |
 Ice Queen1 2004-09-27 . chapter 2You know, you have managed something not even my best friends could do. You actually made me *like* small children. This is an extremely good piece, and let no one tell you otherwise. You captured the emotions of saying good-bye to a loved one perfectly. I hope you continue writing! |
 grumpy 2004-09-26 . chapter 2 very good story and very heartbreaking, needed lots of tissues for this one. So glad that Gilraen brought Estel back. |
 iheartlancelet 2004-09-25 . chapter 2omigosh, that was good, that was really really good!
i know this is a late review, and i don't normally bother to review, but OMG this was just too heartbreakingly well written, and i'm totally crying my eyes out.
estel and elrond were MEANT TO BE TOGETHER (not in a nasty way) and they can NEVER be separated!! arghh!
*huggles*
Litzy.
ps. i'm adding this to my favorites!! :o) |
 jacquelinestel 2004-09-25 . chapter 2This was so well written that I'm crying my eyes out! I really love what you can do with angst and a good idea! Thank you for this lovely story! |
 Dragon Confused 2004-09-25 . chapter 2Aww! That was sweet and nice, but it felt that you had spoiled it somewhat by putting the song in. Your writing was really good and it didn't need the crutch of the song which broke up the flow of the story.
In my opinion anyway, but then I just don't like songfics. |
 Marchwriter 2004-09-25 . chapter 2Aw. Such a tender ending. Thank you for that. This nearly made me cry!
~Lady of Light~ |
 Marchwriter 2004-09-25 . chapter 1Aw, little Estel is so cute. Can I keep him?
This is a very sad and original story. I like it!
~Lady of Light~ |
 Lirenel 2004-09-25 . chapter 2Oh i want to cry! That must have been the sweetest story I have ever read. There are definately tears in my eyes. |