Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: The Bottle

epalladino
2006-03-22
ch 1,
abuseVery romantic. Thank you, Beth Palladino
Terry L. Gardner
2006-01-17
ch 1,
abuseThis story is so touching, so tender, so moving.
GratefullyDead
2005-03-13
ch 1,
abuseOh yah, no doubts here that Capt. Gregg and Carolyn Muir were fated to meet each other.
A lovely story, really.
mrsscatz
2005-01-29
ch 1,
abusesweet story. Proving that they were soul mates though born years apart.
Anabelle Lael
2004-09-13
ch 1,
abuseHow romantic to find a message of love through the years.I loved when the Captain said at the end that the message had arrived to whom it was sent. Just beautiful.
ANOTHERGAMMFAN
2004-07-08
ch 1, anon.
abuseNice story. Very sweet and heartwarming. You have caught the flavor of the show very well. I only have one slight problem with it. You really should invest in a good spellcheck/grammar check system, or perhaps take on the services of a beta reader.

There are several mis-spellings / missing words / wrong words for what I think you meant to write in several places in the story, which are rather distracting. Too for to -- alluded for eluded, for example. Other than that, I like it very much and hope you continue writing!
Karmyn
2004-07-06
ch 1,
abuseLovely, very touching story. I very much enjoyed reading this. Very realistic. I can see the characters acting this way. Very romantic. I do hope you plan to write more.
trueGAMMfan
2004-07-05
ch 1, anon.
abuseLovely story! Sweetly romantic. Hope to see more of your work posted soon.
CottageGhost
2004-07-04
ch 1,
abuseThis was really sweet! I like the idea that Carolyn has been haunting Daniel's dreams since before they even met -- very nice! I also really enjoyed the scene on the ship at night, with Daniel making his rounds, as any good captain most likely does. The scene with the ship's cat was a nice touch, also :-) And the ending was as it should be -- destiny works in mysterious ways, after all. Very nice read, indeed -- thanks for sharing!

Chantal
RevSue
2004-07-03
ch 1,
abuseThanks for another EXCELLENT GAMM story!! Please keep writing them! (We'll have you hooked yet! LOL)
Susan
Anne
2004-07-03
ch 1, anon.
abuseJust beautiful your story. Very sweet. Thanks for a another great read.
lovecelest
2004-07-03
ch 1,
abuseThis story is sweet, but a little sticky. I mean what are the chances of the bottle actually coming up on shore by Gull Cottage. However, I do like the ment for each other for all eternity angle.
jtbwriter
2004-07-03
ch 1,
abuseI like this story-very romantic and sweet.

The fact that the Captain first gets angry then realizes that his message from long ago has found it's inspiration works so well.

I like to think that like the actors who portrayed them, the Captain and Carolyn are together for all time.

Thanks!
Mary
2004-07-02
ch 1, anon.
abuseVery sweet story. I love the "Message in a Bottle" angle! These two souls were simply destined to find each other!

Thanks for sharing this with us!
Return to Top