Sad but really good story.

I have read thsi fic a number of times, i'm really fond of his story, although sad it's still one of the best put together stories

Thought I'd reviewed this before but as I didn't I shall now. I liked the story very much even though I don't much care for song fics. Reading this filled me with so many questions and I like that in a story, something that makes me think and wonder and wish. I also found it very ironic that the mutant who's memories were wiped so long ago only wants to forget now, that is all except for the good that the horror brought - Ororo. Very nice.

This is a really sad but hopeful fic, like NemB, said. I really love the ending, and how Ororo told Logan that as long as they got eachother there can still be hope. Fics like these are very inspiring. Really loved it

Beautiful. Wonderful story. So sad, yet hopeful. Very, very good. The scenes you show here are very efficient - just what we need to see to propel the story along but we also get the emotional nudge the story calls for. Again, very good job and I look forward to more of your stories.