A great story. Very well written.

Wow. This was so amazingly elegant; it was so reminiscent of Tolkein's actual work, I had to do a double-take. You had all of the fantastic elements here that made LotR great, and the ending is cold and sad. Wonderful job.

Aww, poor Castamir...y'know, I never really thought of him nicely (I always thought the crown by Eldacar was unrightly taken)...but this had swayed my mine a little...

Great fic; beautiful and orginal, a perfect combitnation.