 LOTRlover1066 2007-02-23 . chapter 8That was a good little story. It definitely kept Denethor's attitude towards Faramir following his mother's death accurate. please keep writing. |
 lindahoyland 2005-06-01 . chapter 8A very nice ending.I guess the othe other referred to is Aragorn ?I've enjoyed this story very much. |
 Elenhin 2005-05-16 . chapter 7Very amusing, you never can tell when there is a wizard sneaking around.
A good thing too that he watches out for Faramir, Denethor appeared to have lost it for a bit there.
Kindest Regards, Elenhin |
 lindahoyland 2005-05-15 . chapter 7You had me worried about Faramir's safety, good for Gandalf !His mother was foolish to ride when pregnant so faramir can hardly be blamed. |
 crazypenguin4 2005-01-18 . chapter 6awesome story so far!! it is written very well. I cant wait to read what happens next!! |
 Rosie26 2005-01-18 . chapter 6Please update soon! This is a very enjoyable series, and I like the original idea for the titles of the chapters. What's Denethor going to do? |
 Elenhin 2005-01-18 . chapter 6This is really interesting to read. It seems it shall be longer and deeper than I thought at first.
I am very curious about what shall happen next. The cliff hanger at the end really makes one curious about what is coming.
Kind Regards, Elenhin/Mat the Starchild |
 Midgette 2005-01-13 . chapter 5I like this story and I think it's cool how you have every chapter title a tarot card.
And I would've reviewed earlier and more but my computer screwed up and wouldn't let me. *angry look* |
 ForeverFaramir 2005-01-08 . chapter 3This can't be the end, can it? You have to wite more. I'm really enjoying it.
Update more please
ForeverFaramir |
 destinysgypsy 2005-01-08 . chapter 1Awesome..actually reviewing the whole story up to chap 5 as thats where you were when I read. Love the tarot references |
 Evenstar Elanor 2005-01-07 . chapter 5Wow. It's been a long time! HE will not betray you! Nay, it was he who had enough courage to deny what would've brought all ruin. BOROMIR's the one who would've betrayed you!
okay, going to talk to the author, not to Denethor now. Good job at developing Denethor's "insanity", but i don't like to call it that. Jealousy is a very good explanation to why he hates Faramir and Gandalf together, and it parallels the areas in T and RotK where he is so hideous to his younger son. good job! |
 Boromir 2004-10-03 . chapter 4 Who is the black cloaked person? I assume it's his stupid dad. Why does his dad always frown upon Faramir he hasn't done anything wrong! Please keep going! And please get Faramir away from the jerk of a dad! |
 Happy face 2004-08-25 . chapter 3 Hi! Good Story so far!! try making the chapters longer though... I am eager to see what Mithrandir wants with Faramir. keep up the good work!
:-) |
 Evenstar Elanor 2004-08-24 . chapter 3u spelled Denethor wrong, on more than one occasion, and there are a few typos. other than that, i liked it. "The personal cost did not matter and emotions were to be sublimated." it totally captures, in a few words, Denethor's idea of duty.
i was a bit surprised at Denethor's bluntness and willingness to disclose personal information such as, seeing Faramir pained him, for he saw Finduilas in his face. but i like his bruntness, for it characterizes him, in saving nothing, however harsh, from his son. |
 lindahoyland 2004-08-22 . chapter 3Poor Faramir, I feel sorry for him.I'm enjoying this story. |