Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: The Sorting Hat's Sad Song
shadow6116
2009-05-02 . chapter 1
WOW... Really intense
SamGryffinclaw
2008-03-29 . chapter 1
Wow... that was REALLY good. A sort of abrupt ending, but VERY good.
Nyi
2006-06-16 . chapter 1
Uhh.. =) ..
Its sad.. But I like it.. It shows the dark side
of the founders. How they treated the poor Salazar..
He didn't deserved that!! He was only following
his desires and thoughts.. you know? .. =(

I'm sorry for the spellings and grammar mistakes..
I'm Spanish.. I don't know how to speak english very well
But I'm learning !! =D
Jeannie
2004-12-26 . chapter 1
I liked your interpertation of the founders, most peole focus on the whole slythern/grifendor rift. Even though it was real sad I really liked how you showed the founders all being felled because they let their difrences divide them, much like what happens to the Slytherens now, and because of that rift they all fall into the darkness. Poetic and realistic

PS: Glad you changed the origan of the Sorting hat into SLytheren's hat. It's kinda annoying how everything is so Grifendor in the books. Hary the heir..the hat...most of the adults who get screen time unless they're evil...
HaruRockz17
2004-12-22 . chapter 1
ARGH! DAMMIT YOU!! OPEN UP THE REVIEW THING!

...o, my pop-up blocker was on O.o

Very cool and very deep. I liked the last part. Wouldnt mind doing that really, except I'm attached to a bungee cord ^_^

it wud be fun!
Delete Account Please
2004-11-28 . chapter 1
Good job!
Red Eyed Stranger
2004-10-03 . chapter 1
your poetry is so good! shame that all the founders had serious problems O.o bit like me!
Moon Archer
2004-09-17 . chapter 1
Super good, interesting poem. The rythem and rhymes are great. Great job with it.
J.E.A.R.K.Potter
2004-09-14 . chapter 1
Odd. I'd never thought of something like this happening to the founders... Anyways, it was wonderful. Sad, but wonderful. ~Jackie~ (J.E.A.R.K.Potter)
schlimazel
2004-08-24 . chapter 1
It was...interesting. I liked the poem, but the end was a bit cheezy. No, very cheezy. But I liked the rest a lot.
RavenAmeraDreams
2004-08-17 . chapter 1
Oh my...wow! So sad...depressing...I like it! It's amazin! How ever did you think it up? I like it very much, I'dlike to see more of your works!
nightchild87
2004-07-31 . chapter 1
wow... very different... and it hits hard especially the last part about helga... i love it...

~mandalia
Darkest Desire
2004-07-31 . chapter 1
Interesting poem. It was good; I liked it. It's way different than anything I've seen before and, even though in the end all of the founders died, you made it work. You did very well on making sure everything rhymed (even though you had to stretch it a little for some.) It's kind of vague at parts; I didn't exactly understand until I read the end that all of them so far had died. But still, very good. ;)
Meranda
2004-07-31 . chapter 1
hey!
that was really good, keep writing more harry potter
related stories.
*~* Cheers! *~*
Meranda Radcliffe (lol)
lamia animus
2004-07-31 . chapter 1
i've read all your posts and much 2 my surprise i've liked them all. but...YOU'RE CRAZY
(and probably have a death wish)
Return to Top