Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Pasts Imperfect - Page 1 of 2
danita3
2009-10-19 . chapter 4
=D , awesome story , got me butterflies in my stomach , and in order for a story to do that it has to be damn good :D
Sakura123
2008-04-08 . chapter 4
Hi:

I read this story for a second time and then wandered off someplace else, forgetting to review. I seriously did enjoy this story and to addition, Jean was pregnant (O_O) and they were married~![sweet!]. The illustration of Logan and Scott's friendship (or mere acceptance of each other's presence) was nicely depicted, quite refreshing as well.

The incusion of Nick Fury's connection to Wolverine's past and how his and Cyclops' paths crossed in the path (in a sense) was nicely executed. I loved the character Shelley; I cracked up at her reaction to seeing Scott (funny how kids take after their parents).



All in all, I enjoyed reading this!
Sakura123
crystal cerberus
2007-12-21 . chapter 4
that was really good
Pandora of Ithilien
2006-06-19 . chapter 2
shelley's reaction was great! i loved the business about carbon copies and clones.
Vanzetti
2005-11-14 . chapter 4
This came up on a recommendations list, and I wanted you to know that I enjoyed it immensely -- I really liked the way you shifted focus to Scott's mother (since one hears so much about his father!) and fleshed her out, and I love way the story ended: the model planes in the cabinet and Scott realizing that he gets as much from his mother as from his father.

Lovely and original!
BookJunkie
2005-05-11 . chapter 4
Wow. Kinda depressing that Scotties parents are dead though :( still... I liked it!
Patricia16
2005-04-13 . chapter 4
I loved it u must write more
Pinkchick
2004-12-01 . chapter 4
Hey! I have to praise you for a job well done. This story really got me thinking. I love how you linked Logan and Scott's pasts together. But, it's saddening to think that they'll never know who sabotaged the plane. But at least it got both Logan and Scott to start remembering things. Maybe they'll both move on. It was really good. Good job :)
Jenihenpen
2004-10-24 . chapter 4
Totally adorable! I love it! ^__^
CaptainTish
2004-10-19 . chapter 4
That was great! And the display thing at the end! Wow. I love how you tie everything in with the movies, and I really do hope that this is how things will be after X3. Great job!!
CaptainTish
2004-10-19 . chapter 1
Oh, I so hope that your vision of the post-X3 world comes true! (With everyone at the mansion ALIVE and well!, including Jean)
Ivy3
2004-09-30 . chapter 4
I liked it a lot.
Sue Falkenkralle
2004-08-18 . chapter 4
Cool story! I like it very much! The characterizations, the plot, everything about it!
Well done!
LVM the Ice Queen
2004-08-09 . chapter 2
Hey, your stori's great! I love it!! It so different and well written. Wish I could write like thaty...
Amelia
2004-08-06 . chapter 2
Wel written, I like this story. Update soon, I want to see how Logan is involved in this story.
Return to Top