 Padfoot Reincarnated 2005-12-27 . chapter 1"Who will protect me now, Boromir?" he wept. "Who will guide me, defend me? Who will care about me or even love me now you are no longer here? Who will want me? For I can think of none."
That particular line really resonated with me. The Hurin brothers and Faramir especially are two of my favorite characters. Nice work once again. |
 spiritstallion 2004-10-11 . chapter 1I really loved this songfic Are you going to do more LOTR songfics? |
 Boromir 2004-10-03 . chapter 1 Very good story. Would you do more Boromir death fanfictions? |
 A Monkey's Harp 2004-10-02 . chapter 1*sniffs* Where's my kleenex? I *love* these kind of stories - angst is one of my favorite kinds. (Balanaced by plenty of silly, of course!)
Wonderful.
Harpie |
 CatClawz 2004-09-05 . chapter 1that had good style. i like writing and reading that stuff when i'm in the right mood. it can come out very well like yours. |
 biggstrek 2004-09-01 . chapter 1I never saw Faramir as a 'sook'... but this was good! (Which is saying something, as I'm not really in to songfics).
(BRP) |
 Lady of the Twilight Woods 2004-08-07 . chapter 1Tissue alert! This was beautyful. I sort of felt that way when my grandmother died. |
 Cookie Vavasor 2004-08-07 . chapter 1Aw... so sad! I don't even read LOTR fanfiction but I read it only cos it was by you. Really good. I wrote a song fic to Slipped away too but didn't put it up yet ... so ... yeah ... |
 Faramir1017 2004-08-07 . chapter 1 If no one has yet told you this, YOU ARE GREAT! I love this Fanfic so much! Its very Angsty!! I love it! You are so good, the way you described Faramir's feelings. It could be added in the movie. No, I'm serious! what you wrote is EXACTLY what I see in Faramir's eyes! You have no idea how good this Fanfic is to me. May the Valor bless you! :) |
 shie1dmaidenofrohan 2004-08-07 . chapter 1Oh... this is so sad!! Poor Faramir... |
 lucidity 2004-08-07 . chapter 1This is fantastic! I just love Boromir and Faramir is truly ripe for all manner af angst. His life must've been dreadful for so many years.
I'd love to read more about either of these two characters--or, dare I say it, Haldir! Okay, it's true, those are my true favorites of LOTR.
More, please, may I have some more, sir (okay madam). |
 Rosie26 2004-08-07 . chapter 1OMG, can someone please get me a new box of tissues...my emotions are in shreds. Beautiful, absolutely beautiful. And sad obviously. Don't you just want to give him a hug and tell him that someone cares! |
 Lord Elrond of Hogwarts 2004-08-06 . chapter 1Very good Catmint!! Extremely good, especially wiht the character's feelings. You never fail to impress me with every story. It's great how you can go to on the floor laughing to death with your humor and then so angsty. *CHEERS* I feel so bad for Faramir. That is exactly how I thought it would be. I wanna go and comfort him, the poor thing. Thank Iluvatar for Eowyn!! Stupid Denethor! Great story!! |