Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Until The Cherry Blossoms Fall - Page 1 of 2
Jay-Chan
2004-10-12 . chapter 2
That was incredibly well written. I'm very open to (although I don't practice) incest, yoai, yuri, and anything else you probobly want to throw in there, so I enjoyed your story a lot. I like how you touched upon the comfort between Kei-kun and Haruka. It was something I always knew was there, but I never really thought about romantically. Another was that you put in Keitaro's point of veiw too. I liked that. One more good thing, was the way you described Haruka revisiting the fact she'd never have a family. The way you portrayed it really made me feel it. ^_^ You're a wonderful author, and I hope to read some more of your work.
The other guy
2004-09-28 . chapter 2
Aww...I was hoping it to end a haruka/keitaro fic. O well. It was good though. I like odd pairings. Isn't there like only 1 other h/k fic? GOOD WRITING, keep it up.
Modulated
2004-08-24 . chapter 1
Im sorry, But I really gotta say the obvious here, the peice well written and all but its just so... vile. Seriously, for the love of all that is good in this world, write a different fan fic.
jennyjennai
2004-08-23 . chapter 1
I honestly think this is a beautiful love story that ended sadly, tragically even. I believe that Haruka is Keitaro's cousin, but I'm not even sure the relation is that close. Even Kanako was blood-related to Keitaro, so what's the big deal? You were successful in writing this tastefully and well. Just wished the two lovers would have ended up differently. Excellent!
sherazard
2004-08-21 . chapter 1
My 'non-canon pairing' fetish pops up once more.

An absolute beautiful piece of work. Realistic, bittersweet and romantic. I love it. Honestly, I don't really see a problem with incest; love is love and people shouldn't try to label it or classify it. Emotions are too abstract for that.

Aside from that little tidbit, it's a good fic. Way to go. :)
Hideki Hirameshi
2004-08-20 . chapter 1
Wow. A very well-written Haruka-Keitaro fanfiction. Very rare.

You know, I agree with everybody that this pairing is downright impossible, but this magnificent writing is too good to pass up.

The special mutual understanding between these characters puts things here in perspective, as this one kind of shows Haruka's gentle side. I have never seen anyone write about Haruka's thoughts like this one, so I initially thought you went out of character there. The ending, however, probably explains everything that you've set-up, especially the plot and the situations that follow in Keitaro's life.

Again, a rare find about impossible character pairings. Keep it up!
aondehafka
2004-08-20 . chapter 1
Arrggh! What does it say about me that I found the eventual Keitaro-Naru ending more disgusting than the Keitaro-Haruka affair? Hurry up and write more 'Once in a Blue Moon' so I can have something to read and thoroughly enjoy that doesn't raise such disquieting questions! Seriously, though, this was a very well-written story. Engaging, enjoyable (in that 'remember that the guy getting it on with his aunt is just an anime character' sort of way), and thought-provoking. Particularly liked Haruka's mix of wistfulness and pragmatism.

My only real quibble is a personal one that has nothing to do with the absolute quality of the story. But my eternal anti-Keitaro-Naru bias would have vastly preferred to see the Haruka thing mature Keitaro and build his self-confidence to the point where he puts Naru completely behind him and falls for someone else (Mutsumi being the person that I think would work best within such a framework), rather than just allowing him to work it out with Narusegawa-san.

Putting aside wistful thoughts of what might have been, I'll close by saying well done, good job, thanks for sharing, and get back to work on 'Once in a Blue Moon'. ;)
Demon King Piccolo
2004-08-19 . chapter 1
It was rather interesting. I honestly would have liked to read more. It was still a good read, nonetheless.
SimmyC
2004-08-18 . chapter 1
You did pretty well. And I'd say, this is a good story. Especially for a concept that is just plain...icky. Yeah, I have a relatively open mind. And since it is fiction...not that bad. But still, the idea with Keitaro...with his aunt?
Kei-kun
2004-08-18 . chapter 1
Well it was a very interesting story. I guess you have to have an opened mind to these kinds of things. In a way I could see those two becoming a couple but Im just not sure how though, ya'know with the family relations and all. Anyay nice story.
Exodius
2004-08-18 . chapter 1
Great Story, i'd perosonally always been a fan of the Haruka/Keitaro Possibility but i've seen extremely few stories written of this couple. probably becuase "incest is bad" in the real world i view at as such but in the anime world its totally cool and most or part of the reason why i read Angel Sanctuary and Lament of the Lamb.

Anywho I doubt i'll see many Haruka/Keitaro Fics on the net so if you get around to writing another one i'd love to read it.
TornadoReviewer
2004-08-18 . chapter 1
I think that this is the first , and a mean Firs Keitaro/Haruka fic I have seen.
Well , the only problem is that she i his aunt...
But on the other hand this is a fanfic...just a fanfic.For the first time it's hard for me to write a review:]
I'll hold my opinion until uptade.
St.Jack
2004-08-17 . chapter 1
This season it seems that Haruka/Keitaro is in :)

An interestingly one-sided view, You gloss over the "family" angle a little, but that's understandable in a short like this.

all in all short, sweet and ripe for an amusing sequel called "Flying High: Keitaro's admission to Naru"

With regards to rare pairings:
I have yet to see a Tsuruko/Keitaro (believable or otherwise) and would very much like to :)
HinaGuy749
2004-08-17 . chapter 1
Wow, that was pretty damn good, though I don't really agree with the bitter-sweet ending, it gives the story a more...I don't know...a certain feeling of believability that just makes it an emotional thing to read. And about the whole incest thing, it's not my preference but the way I see it is if you really love a person enough you shouldn't let things like that get in the way as long as you don't try and have a kid together 'cause then you could be gambling with the health of your kid so just adopt. Anyways this was just an awesome fic, I really enjoyed reading it, keep up the awesome work. Peace w/ chicken grease!
3line
2004-08-17 . chapter 1
Whoa! First that story Family Affairs, now this. I love it; it's so iconoclastic.

So far it's decently written, and I can only wait for more.
Return to Top