 asdfjkl; 2009-04-10 . chapter 1 i adore finrod. |
 Halfwest 2005-08-20 . chapter 1I'm just going to sit here and purr at you for a little while, kay? :D
Lovely piece. |
 alena 2004-09-26 . chapter 1Oh, wow. There is a rhythm to the words, which is deeply moving in a way that I can't exactly describe. It's so very very Finrod.
And the last line...*cries* |
 Marchwriter 2004-09-15 . chapter 1* sitting awestruck before the keyboard *
This was... INCREDIBLE!
Such power and music in your words. So much in so little. What a powerful story and so beautiful in its quest for hope amidst darkness.
Many thanks for this little snippet.
~Lady of Light~ |
 Archaic Scribe 2004-09-13 . chapter 1This is an intimate look at Finrod's imprisionment and a good portrayal of his raw thought.
My favorite imagery from you in this vignette is "...brash grace..." I think I had shivers going down my spine at that fierce imagery.
Nicely done! I am glad to have happened upon this delightful, and short piece. The length of it gives it that much more meaning, I think and adds to the instensity of the situation Finrod has been placed in by Sauron. |
 Itarille 2004-09-12 . chapter 1This is beautiful, and so sad. Very well done. |
 Evenstar Elanor 2004-09-10 . chapter 1i'm speechless, which is something u don't hear very often.
WOW
is all i can say. i mean, u incorporated all that is lovely and fair about Aman (well isn't everything) and all the references to Finarfin, and the Valar/Valier, and how he at first, thinks he's hallucinating, and that Sauron (i was a bit surprised @ that reference. why not Morgoth?) controls even his mind, but then he becomes defiant, and realizes that Sauron must be angry that he cannot control Finrod's mind.
your word usage is stunning, and i just love all the references... must go onto my fav stories. gah, u should check that list. there's like 4 stories from u, plus the fav authors list! |
 Sphinx 2004-09-10 . chapter 1Intensely desperate. Finrod really came through, although it was rather heartbreaking considering his normal descriptions in the Silm. The last line is superb.
Sphinx |
 Ellie 2004-09-09 . chapter 1 Nice imagery and memories amidst the darkness. |
 Unsung Heroine 2004-09-09 . chapter 1 This is wonderful. Simply wonderful. It nearly had me crying. Oh yeah, things as such do this to me from time to time... *smile* |
 The-MarmaladeCat1 2004-09-09 . chapter 1I suppose the best praise I can give you is that you do indeed write with the poetry and grace of an elf of those times. |
 Skycat14 2004-09-08 . chapter 1 Wonderful! Extremely Haunting! I love how you use such rich detail in describing things. Keep it up! |