This is the best fanfic I have ever read! You clearly have a gift and I would love it if you posted the other stories you mentioned on your home page.

A beautifully written story. :) I love how your OCs were interwoven with all the canon characters so well they seemed to belong together. :)

I am really liking the fact that the two teens are not familiar with LOTR so do not have to deal with knowing what is going to happen, and it is interesting that they do not know each other. :)

This is a wonderful story. You are very talented. Thanks for writing your stories.

so since it would be around '55 in thomas and rebecca's time, is thomas' dad in the vietnam war? hmmmm...

lol not that its relevant to the story, but where did Thomas learn geography? the biggest country is not the US, but Russia

loved this chapter

Radbooks, I never really read this whole story but have been going back through old fics to see if I could find anything *new*. Love this story. Your OCs are very realistic and don't intrude on canon at all. Am up to chapter 11. Thanks for a terrific read. I needed it!

For some odd reason I can't help but think of Celeborn as a grumpy old pessimist with Galadriel as some kind of "perker-upper" With a "after long years of life!" to Celeborns "You'll all die..". Hahaha, With the familarity you created with Aragorn and Galadriel and Celeborn, I got this mind-scene of a breakfast in the treetops with a very young Estel and a Celeborn being hushed by Galadriel by the way of lembas bread stuffed into his mouth, hindering him from saying something completely inappropiate and scare the poor child. Hehe, love the story! :D

Hi! You know, I'm rereading this absolutely delightful story, and it just occurred to me that, while on Earth buttons may be a relatively recent invention, in Middle Earth buttons were certainly known. For example, as far as I remember, Bilbo lost a good many buttons when he escaped the goblin tunnels after he had found the ring and escaped Gollum.

I LOVED your story...until you let thomas and rebecca fall in love. EW

they so don't fit together! the only thing they have in common is that they are both from eart.its so... EW

not to mention cheesy. its like: oh wait,i need romance, lets have the twoo earthlings fall in love. sigh

as I said, i loved this story, until you made that totaly corny and discusting pairing.

dont think i will read any more, sorry

Hey! I just read the whole story and I totally loved it! I'm on my way to reading the sequel right now and I'll let you know what I think of it when I finish! xoxo

-.- Ok, so they're teens. But still...WIMPS.

-.- I dont know of any 20-ish year old guys who would act so wimpy...

This is one of the best LOTR stories out there i was up all night reading it! it's amazing!

Thank You!

This was great; I loved it all the way through!