Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: This Present Darkness - Page 1 of 123
Dawn 'n' Dusk
2009-07-05 . chapter 61
I usually stray away from fics like this. Truly, I do. But as soon as I read the beginning chapter, I was captivated. You are a fantastically talented writer. I would make the suggestion you become a full time author in the 'real world', but most fanfic writers prefer to stay in fantasy.

I'll be back soon for some more of your fabu-licious stories!

D&D
artgirl87
2009-06-30 . chapter 61
Amazing. I like your oath...good idea. I hate coming across a story and finding out that it will probably never be complete. I personally cant wait for the the hobbit to come out. Its my favorite! Just to let you know I am a Senior GFA major at the MD Institute College of Art in Baltimore and I have been doodling this story!...but the downside is that I am not good at photoshop, but I can draw. If I did draw something up, where do I send it too? my email is . I hope you get many offers! Look for an illustration major!
Calenharn
2009-06-28 . chapter 61
As sad as I am to see the end of this riveting tale, I have to say that you summed it up just about perfectly, giving us, in turns, humor, angst, acceptance, and hope.

It was not to be expected that after all that has passed, Legolas would be "normal" - and I am glad to see that you addressed that. With the return of the Call, however, there is hope that one day, in Valinor, he will be fully restored.

Similarly (although, being focused on Legolas, the thought never occurred to me - although it should have), it was only to be expected that Aragorn would suffer his own lingering trauma. In this vein, it was a nice touch working in Faramir's dreams of the pyre, and the Dwarven sigin-narag. (One can only guess at what dreams Gimli might have.)

And yet there is hope - hope for Legolas' eventual complete spiritual restoration, and hope for Legolas and Aragorn's friendship. In their discussion and plans for the orc hunt, we can see a new beginning - a new (echoed in the sunrise) dawn.

So very well done.
The Visitor
2009-06-26 . chapter 61
Amazing.

I can't believe we've finally made it to the end. The ending was beautiful, hopeful with a touch lingering sorrow. You've invested so much of yourself into this story, and I hope your book plans go well. You deserve all the praise you've garnered over the years. I thank you sincerely for sharing this with us.

Until next time!
Erin
2009-06-26 . chapter 61
Best story I have ever read. Perfect ending and I'm glad you didn't make everyone completely healed. Good work!
sam611
2009-06-25 . chapter 61
HI!! Wonderful ending! you made cry, literaly. util we meet again
sam
vectis
2009-06-24 . chapter 61
I'm glad that you don't do short, or sweet, for this was a great concluding chapter for this epic tale. It is more a hopeful than a happy ending, which considering that none of the characters will have escaped unscarred by the events depicted, is a very realistic one. (There were times during this tale that I thought it would be impossible for you to give this a satisfactory conclusion - sorry, I was wrong to doubt you, Lamiel!)
There were so many scenes in this story that left me feeling that I had watched the action rather than read it, a fact due entirely to your vivid and detailed descriptions. Thank you so much for the image of 'Juggling Elves' - it still makes me smile even now.
To publish this story in a hard copy is a great idea and I wish you well with the project - sadly as my printer was not even up to the task of printing each chapter and I'm woefully lacking in artistic talents I have no help or assistance to trade.
I hope this story remains on this site for a long time to come as I have already spotted details in this tale that I missed the first time. Thank you again for such an absorbing story and best wishes for you in your future endeavours.
Beverly
2009-06-23 . chapter 61
Excellent! Splendid! Magnificent! I could go on and on. From the first line on the first page, I have loved this story. As someone else said, it is bittersweet. I'm thankful that Legolas recovered as well as he did, but I still feel pain at his loss of so much. I'm so happy that you will be writing more stories (doing the happy dance)and will be looking forward to reading them.

You deserve every word of praise heaped upon you and every award presented to you.

Thank you.
And, as always,
Peace
Beverly
Calenlass Greenleaf1
2009-06-23 . chapter 61
Such a beautiful ending. Angsty, with a bit of lingering sadness, but the light-hearted note at then end ties it up perfectly.

I would love to do a book cover, but my scanner broke...still haven't got that fixed yet. So I hope someone can come up with a great cover for this story. :)

Thank you so much for writing!

~Cal
leralonde
2009-06-22 . chapter 61
You couldn't have written a more perfect ending. It was certainly sweet enough for me. When I think back to the middle of the story, I never would have dreamed that things could have turned out as well as they did. You said you were going to bring their friendship down to the bare bones and you did that and built it back up as no one else could. I loved it when Legolas presented the Chain of Oropher to Aragorn. When Aragorn looked away as Legolas relayed Thranduil's message, I could feel the lump in his throat that he must have had. He still doesn't feel worthy. But what is this emptiness that Arwen says Legolas' has? The convesation seemed to veer off somewhere and I didn't find an answer. Or maybe I just missed it. I liked how Legolas described himself as healed but scarred. I'm looking forward to lots of short stories from you. Every one will be a blessing.
Jebb
2009-06-22 . chapter 61
Hi well, I never thought the day would come but we now have the final chapter and as with the rest of the story there was angst and unhappiness but also some hope for the future.
There were times when the power of this story all but swept me away and I was only reading it!
But in the end we come back to the strength and durability of friendship and love and a reasonably 'happy' ending
Thank you
Naledi
2009-06-22 . chapter 61
That was the perfect end to an enthralling story. As much as I want to see Legolas completely healed and happy, I agree that it just could not happen this side of the sea. Far better to end with hope.

Thank you so much for sharing this with us. I look forward to your future tales.
mffantasia
2009-06-22 . chapter 61
Lamile,
I want to congratule you for this story, it is so beautiful and sad...it is an ode to friendship, I don't know wht to say, I just loved it.

The final scene, in the balcony, it was just perfect. Good luck with your book, I'm not good in photoshop, so I can not offer my help.

Thank for this story, I will be waiting for more of your stories, now if I can fill my shopping cart, can we have one with Legolas and Faramir? they shared Ithilien, I'm sure that they have a lot of interaction, and your portrait of Faramir and Eowyn was perfect...Anyway, I will read whatever you post.

Fantasia.
Robinscat
2009-06-22 . chapter 61
You did it! You finished it! I am so pleased and happy... and sad, too. For it is finished. "sniff"

As others have mentioned, I like how the closing chapter begins as the opening one did, even to the same wording, but how different the meaning and feelings of those words. And I am glad you did not have a mushy meeting of the three. So much more realistic, the formal words and actions.

You ended the story perfectly, not all wounds are healed without some scarring, but life goes on. There are orcs to kill!

I once told you I was painting some scenes from your story. One is almost done, I will send it on to you. It would not be worthy of cover art, but it is yours.

Thank you for your gift.
Robin
CAH
2009-06-22 . chapter 61
Everyone seems happy or as happy as they can be. I still feel sorry for Legolas who lost the most; epsecially Arwen. How hard that must be for him.

So it looks as though Thranduil forgives Aragorn. He truly is a great king, isn't he?

I would love to see one last chapter of Legolas in Valinor after being there awhile. Is he whole again?

Thanks for a wonderful story and I'm looking forward to reading more!
Return to Top