 thrnbrooke 2007-07-18 . chapter 1Oh how sad! I wonder if Harry had of lived would Pansy be Draco's wife... |
 Catmint 2006-01-19 . chapter 1I'm sitting here with tears in my eyes. This is absolutely heartbreaking. You've captured Severus' pain wonderfully and I love your use of Lily. I felt the emotions of both of them. *sniffle* |
 dead feather 2004-12-04 . chapter 1I'd say very in character. good one |
 Fate 2004-10-17 . chapter 1 absolutely wonderful!
This piece was beautifully written, well done! |
 Linden 2004-10-09 . chapter 1 The emotions were perfect and i adored every bittersweet line. |
 Lillei 2004-09-30 . chapter 1 Wow. This was amazing. |
 ecce_echo 2004-09-25 . chapter 1 This was beautiful, chest burning, sobbingly beautiful. You just hit, dead on, the emotional core and held and wrung till it was empty. |
 Jaded Angel8 2004-09-25 . chapter 1That's so sad, but sweet.
.
JA |
 SnowyBlackOwl (not logged in) 2004-09-23 . chapter 1 Hey there, D! This was so sad! I like this, and I hope you make another! |
 Amscray 2004-09-23 . chapter 1 "Chicks dig giant robots."- Jamie
Good chapter, even though I think Potter is a snarky bastard. It's kind of funny that Lily is a bit of a hypocrite. Fifth year, the only one who would "help" her was Snape while that SOB made fun of her. Then she ends up with that batarde, and says she would never leave him. Well then, why is she married to that jackass?
Keep up the good work.
PS: This wasn't a flame. I think it's a very good story even though I cannot stand Potter. He doesn't deserve Lily anymore than Snape does.
Later. |
 starlollie 2004-09-23 . chapter 1give me a moment while I curl in a ball and cry my eyes out...real tears not just rain. Gees that was so sad. Severus and lily :(And Draco loved Harry? And the poem...its gonna take me all day to recover from this. Good job. |
 after sex cigarette 2004-09-23 . chapter 1Wow...It was wierd, but the feelings and descriptions seemed to leap off the page. Brutal hinesty in what Severus was thinking, feeling and saying. It was really good. |
 angelsammi 2004-09-23 . chapter 1Ok.. This story is fab.. I'd always loved angst.. But sorry Im a lil blur.. Who died? Harry? I like the poem by John Donne.. Very nice.. |