I love the story great work. Nice descriptive language, and I think Minerva needs to let her hair down more often.

Tears are streaming down my face. I'm crying. Your fic really touched me. McGonagall is my favourite character and you portrayed her perfectly. I'm comend you for sticking by your decision and going through with it. I don't think I would have been able to. The poems and songs fit wonderfully and make me want to cry even more. This really is a brilliant fic and you are a very talented writer. Thank you ever so much for sharing! Minerva's goodbyes were beautiful, heart wrentching, but beautiful! The tears are still falling...

PiER

I loved this story so much! I was so sad at the end, but it was really well written and the way you portrayed Minerva was great!

I can't help but say it. I cried. This is one of the best stories I've ever read. It was so detailed that it feels like you're watching it through the monitor. I absolutely loved it, and cried. You really did kill McGonagall! But if I had to pick any author here to do it, I'd pick you. Most people would botch it up somehow ^_^

You are truly a great and gifted writer.

Wow your entire story was awesome. I laughed and cryed. Excellently written. Keep up the good work.

~Katelynn, A HUGE McGonagall and Dumbledore Shipper Fan~

another brilliant chapter. as much as i wish minerva could live, i know you have done a perfect job and even joanne would enjoy it. best of luck with future stories. i will definately read them. from you huge fan, simone

I've been avoiding this fic as I couldn't face the outcome. I commend for sticking with it and doing it well.

congrats! you finished this story! It's so sad, but yet wonderfuly done. I hope to see more from you, with your fantastic writing.

*sniff* i'm sorry i havn't been reviewing. i've
was banned from the internet. i love this story, it's so well written, emotional, and beautiful. u must write more, but please, not so sad! i'm crying. ur a brilliant writer. ttfn! luv tigger ~x~x~

First of all: It's a great story... And that's really a compliment because usually I just refuse to read stories where either Min or Albus die. But even though I'm still crying I honestly enjoyed your story. Great writing - very sensitively. Keep going!

Hugs, Rikki

With or Without you is originaly done by U2. Great story though!

...wow. I felt as though I was there. A truly beautiful piece. -bigkihap

I cried like a baby through those last few chapter! Amazing job! I loved this story!

I've really enjoyed reading this fic...you've written Minerva and Albus beautifully. Her death is sad, but I seem to have the bad habit of killing my characters too so I can't blame you.
I love the song with or without you and I'm so glad you included it. You're right, the music is heart-wrenching. Thanks for the wonderful story!

sobs, I was fine till I reached the par where Albus stood and said his word and then the tears came.