Really Good! Poor Harry and Sirius :(

WRITE WRITE WRITE WRITE

Add on.

Update soon!

Awesome story, keep it up.

How old is Harry? I like it so far. Poor Padfoot!

Im glad dumbledore is going to be in on it. like i said great so far

I've always wondered what it would be like if moony found out. great fic, i love it.

FINALY! I'd given up hope! I thought you'd been attaked by death eaters or somthing...but still worth waiting for.

i like this. it very good. i don't have any idea on a title, but something will come to you eventually. : ) i hope that you can update soon! i'm putting you on author alert, so i will be watching.
~emikae

Good chapter. Can't wait for the update, can't think of a title still..

Good story! Of course, the only title I can think of to help you out there is the most unoriginal one which you probably already thought of and decided not to use, "What If"

Please update soon!

Nice, I like the charecterisation, lupin reads very lupin-like but I'll have to see more to think more. nice start, i'll keep reading. if you keep writing :D