 David Fishwick 2008-10-16 . chapter 47Cool idea and thanks for writing. I liked Sirius telling Fudge off. |
 cyiusblack 2008-04-24 . chapter 47super story |
 well 2007-07-06 . chapter 7 now would have been the best time for harry to bring up the fact that the weasels stayed out of the order the first go round (OOTP) the fact that sirius was actually doing something while they hid in their hovel. romaticizing molly sticking up for her kids is kind of bs, the point being she wanted harry in her brood when sirius was his rightful gaurdian. sirius wanted to tell him the truth and molly wanted to stick her tit in his mouth. |
 b 2007-07-06 . chapter 6 bit out of character for harry to sit back and let people disparage sirius and lupin wasnt it? ** the weasels and snape they say something out of line and you have lupin appologize. |
 LupinLover88 2007-03-18 . chapter 47Omg, do you have to make it a cliff-hanger? Okay, I already knew about it since I've read the story before, but still! |
 LupinLover88 2007-03-18 . chapter 33Extraordinary scene there that last one. I don't know how you write like that. I can't imagine where all the creativeness, images, and pictures come from in your mind. It's something that I just don't have. My boyfriend does, but I'm just not one of them. Anyways, ttyl I'll read on. |
 LupinLover88 2007-03-17 . chapter 7lol I think that's one of my favorite chapters. I don't know, haven't read the story in a while, but I like this chapter very much. It explains a lot of things you know? Anyways, I shall read on. |
 LupinLover88 2007-03-16 . chapter 2Hey! It's me again, don't know if you remember me. I wonder when you're going to finish the sequel of this story. However, I know I haven't read this story in ages, so am reading it now since I've nothing better to do than be entertained. lol Hope to talk to you soon! |
 lilacBookstar 2007-02-23 . chapter 10Aww you made me cry |
 lilacBookstar 2007-02-23 . chapter 7A beautiful array and contrast of emotions in this chapter. well done |
 lilacBookstar 2007-02-23 . chapter 6How big is this widowsill? Certainly bigger than mine. Nah just kidding, another cool chap
LilacBookstar |
 lilacBookstar 2007-02-23 . chapter 5Guess who's back? This first one's as good as the 2nd. I'm loving it. Love this line; "All right Harry, how about you tell me again why you asked me if you have to go back to the Dursleys? Only this time you tell me the truth."
It's really going to stick in my mind,
LilacBookstar |
 Secret world 2007-01-05 . chapter 5love the chap. finily some one shows the ebilitys that gave Remus the name of the Maraders!
ather people just made him a strict tierd person but all of us know that he has a side that got him the name. I didn't think that harry poisond himself but glad to here that my suspishons were right about it.
last but not lest I read this story that made a varry good point about the vall of dathe being for evil people and that Sirius was not evil si thay could bring him back!
love the story |
 Secret world 2007-01-04 . chapter 2love the story and the way you have put it. but I can't hid the filling that for some reason you like severus snape?
don't take it in a bad way if you do it's just that I thought that it was inposibul thats all.
though remus is another subject what is happening to him I know he is dapressed but I think your hidding something that is going to come up latter on?
other wise I have some last Qustens. You know when sirius died that thay were in the ministy trying to get the profisy about harry and valdimort right. but thay were also hade to go through the room were thay stor the time ternners so why didn't any of them think to go back in time and pervent it from happinig. like have the harry that was going back in time go and stop sirius from entering or something?
don't you think that that would have saved him becaus thay rilly didn't need him at the ministry thay others seemed to have it under control espeshily when Domboldor shoud up I just don't get it that could have saved sirus.(big fan of him and the Maraders!)
and do you rilly think Domboldor is dead?
I don't and the reason way is that in J.K.Rowlings last intervew after the 6th book she said that she wasn't going to say anything about if she was going to wright more then 7 book but she said that she left hints in the 6 books if you read them and payed close attenshon that you would now about some of the things that are going to happen in the 7th book
I myself have read those books 33 times and I have found them.
Domboldor isn't rilly dead because in that varry same book he died in, befor thay left to go get the horcrex he said to harry that "life is but another adventer" and that "if it was his time to go that he was not afrad"...then why would he beg severus not kill him?(hint he is not dead and he is simpilly hidding out to serpris lord voldimort in the end and help harry or some other reason he think is fit that he needed to fack his death and all of us no that he can hide if he needs to he did in the 5th book and no one could find him)
also if you are wondering about the fact that the spell harry was put under came off. thay say in the book that, that could only mean that Domboldor was dead because he didn't have his wand. well I have found the ancer to that to domboldor is said in some of the 6 book that he can do wand less magic.(hint Hint)
and( Domboldor is the strongest wizerd alive do you think that a person like snape could kill him even with the posion domboldor still was a varry strong wizerd)
also about the fack that if she is going to wright another book after the 7th the ancer is yes becaus at the end of the 6th book when he is talking with herminoe and ron by the lake she gives another hint,1. that thay have to go to bills wedding 2. thay have to go to godric's hallow to see his parents graves 3.thay also have to track doun the remanding hercrex's 4. thay have to go after nagini valdimorts snake 5. thay have to defet valdimort himself so those are some clus that let you know that is going to take a long time. also Valdimortwould have hide them well, just look at the cave and that was one of the varry first ones he hide so he was bound to get better at it at some point don't you think?
also another thing I think that someone is going to convince them to finish school first, do you rilly think that remus, molly, arther ,magonigul, mad eye, tonks, and the hole order is going to let them go and not finish it, I don't think so?
and last but not lest I think that ginny is going to some how convince them to let her go along, or shes going to fallow them, or maby harry can't do it by himself because he needs love and he is the only one he loves and vise versa, and she is in the same amount of danger with him or without him because she is a wizley and thay are the biggest family of blood traters known to wizer kind, also because of the tension between arther and lusius Malfo.
(Sorry about it being so long and all but I would apresheat it if you could email me back with your apinons it alwas nice to here someone elses thought on the matters.) |
 Secret world 2007-01-04 . chapter 1love the fic. |