This may surprise you from me, but this is, in my not so humble opinion, the best conceived, best written and most promising attempt at a LOTR/HP crossover I have ever seen. My problems with certain statements in another one of your fics do nothing to detract from your overall excellence as a writer (although: "...the more fair and crystal is the sky/ The uglier seem the clouds that in it fly"). I find it very sad that it should have stopped at the fifth chapter, and sincerly hope that at some point you may find the energy to continue it.

Great story 10/10 plz plz plz update I beg of you

SE

Hey, are you thinking of updating this story ever again? Seriously, it's been a long long time and I think the plot is bloody brilliant! It's one of the best HP and LotR crossovers around here! PLEASE UPDATE!

This is really interesting, especially the part where the Blacks are descended from Aragorn and Arwen. Bellatrix is so awesome - pity she killed Sirius... Can't wait for the next chapter!

very good, I've just finished the last available chapter and I urge you to continue. The whole idea is wonderful, I was simply ecstatic when I heard you'd written a cross over for my two favourite series. Do keep up the good work.

Will Voldemort try to go to the past? Please update soon! =)

This is amazingly good--I'm especially surprised that someone actually managed to make a well-written, interesting crossover. Especially since this has Draco in it! It appears you've quit writing, but if you haven't...please update?

interesting story!

that was a great story, lots of stuff happening... hope to read some more soon :D

Great, great... GREAT!

*blink* Wow, this is... it's really interesting, and very in-character, and, just -- wow!

Probably one of the most plausible HPxLotR crosses that I've seen yet. Neat ^.^

Mae govannen, mellon nîn!
This is really brilliant! The best HPxLotR Xover I've ever read! I really hope, you'll continue writing this?
Please?
Navaer,
Ithiliel

Interesting, Harry Potter characters addicted to LotR. I look forward to seeing where you are going with this.

Wow. I don't suppose you are planning on updating?

Much as I like SR, I do hope you revisit this at some point Really quite a unique and interesting read so far, with a lot of potential to be explored. Thanks!