Share/Save/Bookmark
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Circle that Binds - Reviews: Page 1 of 5

gen x
2008-10-08
ch 8, anon.
abuseNot bad
Dumbledork
2008-10-07
ch 8,
abuseNice chapter.
H3Knuckles
2008-09-24
ch 7,
abuseGood story so far, looking forward to more.

As someone who has no training in any form of fighting, my eyes kind of glaze over when reading overly technical or detailed descriptions of fights. Yours have been pretty good though. There's a nice flow and you do a good job of clearly detailing the fights without getting bogged down in the description. Sorry I can't offer a more critical assessment.

So even though Ranma's able to talk and interact more normally as a girl, she's still affected by the 'dog-fist' training?
sandcrawlr
2008-09-22
ch 8,
abuseI like the update, and the fight scene flowed nicely. No complaints here. :)
recon12
2008-09-22
ch 8,
abusecan ranma fight when he/she is in the right mind or not? is this a ranma/kasmui story or other. i hope its a kasumi/ranma story. nothing agaist the ranma/akane flicks i guest perfer the prior. fight seen not bad. why not have the biker guys clan get ** and state a vendeate agaist the satoames.cause that is how it looks your going.
Rose1948
2008-09-21
ch 8,
abuseHon, I'll take your chapters in any length but super-short. I'll also wait, patiently, for your next update.

I enjoyed this chapter very much. Ranma's POV was quite insightful. Looking forward to seeing how the next chapter shows things.

Take care!
Wonderbee31
2008-09-21
ch 8,
abuseVery good, and since the gang has lived, but hurt, will be curious as to whether they write it off and come back for more, and what all Genma will tell them in the morning.
Wonderbee31
2008-09-21
ch 7,
abuseGood part there, and cannot imagine the pain that these biker punks are going to be in now, and Genma can't let them leave, or else they may tell others about the collar, right?
Lockblade
2008-09-21
ch 8,
abuseWell, I have to say, this story rocks. our grammar is great, and I haven't seen any spelling problems. The only problem I've seen throughout the story is that you switch from an omniscient point of view to Ranma's without warning, and the transition is a little jerky. Other than that, though, keep up the good work!

--Lockblade
deitarion/SSokolow
2008-09-21
ch 8,
abuseI especially like this chapter. The Ranma-POV parts work really well.

As for length, given how quickly you've been updating, have you considered releasing longer chapters less frequently? (just waiting a bit to let the chapter length grow before posting) It's an illustrative hyperbole, but a chapter every month is much more enjoyable than a word every second because it gives the reader time to get back into the story.

I wouldn't have any problem whatsoever with larger, less frequent updates.
ranma girl 14
2008-09-20
ch 8,
abuseNice chapter, can't wait to see what will happen next.
plz update soon! ^_^
Violet Shadows
2008-09-20
ch 8,
abuseGood chapter, I liked it.
ranma girl 14
2008-09-20
ch 7,
abuseI really can't wait to see the next chapter, plz plz plz update fast! ^_^
Rose1948
2008-09-20
ch 7,
abuse::snickers:: Oops. Now he had her, now he don't. ::fol::
Violet Shadows
2008-09-20
ch 7,
abuseHey, if you're going to keep updating with these micro chapters, then don't recombine them afterwards, it messes with the reviews, so you can't review the new chapters once they take the place of the old (if that made sense).
Return to Top