Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Derivations - Page 1 of 11
Johnny-on-the-spot
2009-07-13 . chapter 5
I would be so happy if you were to update this wonderful story! :D
Kaz
2009-03-26 . chapter 5
I very much enjoyed reading what you've written so far of Derivations. I like stories where another dimension of magic is introduced - in this case, familiar magic, inherited magic and other "older magic" that only Dumbledore seems to still practise in the canon story. And you've also brought up two other ideas about HP which I had been wondering about, that of what Lily Evans was really like, and how intelligent the animals could have been.

For some reason I've always found it strange in stories when Dumbledore is portrayed as showing less confident emotions like confusion, etc. He always seemed to - if not already know - then at least have already guessed at what someone was about to divulge to him, or what someone was really thinking. I've never liked a blatantly manipulative Dumbledore either, but I enjoyed his role in this story as a potential antagonist besides Voldemort. I think it's because in changing his character this way, other authors have unfortunately neglected to show how intelligent he really is, and so they give him flaws that are too easily exploitable. But again, I like Dumbledore in Derivations, especially with his ulterior motives.

So yes, it was a fantastic read! I hope you're still committed to this story, and if so, I wish you luck in adding to it.
Bom hasamaki
2008-12-19 . chapter 5
Well, this whole story has piqued my interest. I hope you're feeling better and update sometime soon.

Merry Christmas!
LoneWolf
2008-12-01 . chapter 1
this story is so good! i check back every so often to see if it's been updated, but unfortunately it hasn't. =[
if you're too busy, i understand, but PLEASEPLEASEPLEASE, if you have any time at all, PLEASE update this story.
I'm so anxious to see what happens! =]


- sincerely, your fan,
grace
Elementalmoon
2008-11-24 . chapter 5
I like the way this is going. It is an interesting and new twist on the plot device. I really hope that you come back to this story some day soon. I know that it's been several years now, but I still hold out hope. Very amusing!
fairytopian
2008-07-15 . chapter 5
i hope you dont scrap this story i was really getting into it, please update the chapter soon please!
Supernaturallvr
2008-07-10 . chapter 5
This story is wonderful. I can't wait to see what you will do with it next. I love how you had Lucius as a semi-good guy and Draco as an intelligent human being. I am curious as to what type of 'creature' Harry is and if he will go with his 'family' or not. Please update soon.
BladesoftheValkyrie
2008-06-26 . chapter 5
Wow, this is an amazing story! It's a "creature fic" but without the insta-love that usually accompanies the genre - I'm impressed! I'm a bit sad that you seem to have abandoned it (seriously, this story is very original and well-written), but if you are still looking for a beta I would be more than happy to help! ^_^
Haruka-Hime
2008-05-01 . chapter 4
Uh, never mind, ignore my last question.
Haruka-Hime
2008-05-01 . chapter 2
Is the white thing a wolf of some kind? Or a feline/avian? Ys you can tell, I'm a bit confused on that aspect.
cutecess
2008-01-12 . chapter 5
interesting story!
Enna
2008-01-03 . chapter 5
I REALLY like this... hopefully you haven't given up fully. I'd really do ANYTHING to see more of this. Thanks!
Tazzm
2007-12-31 . chapter 5
Oh wow, really liking your story so far. It's more individualistic than many I've come across, and that always invites me to want to come back and check for updates.
Please, keep up the good work and update soon :)
And if you should find yourself in need of a beta, please email me. I'm very fussy about words, spelling and grammar, and part of my enjoyment so far in this story has been the good english.
dark-wolf-howl
2007-12-13 . chapter 5
brilliant story so far, wonder what type of magical creature it is,please start updating soon
yuis
2007-11-26 . chapter 5
Gosh.

If you ever update this -

I want to know.

+alert
Return to Top