That is *exactly* what my sister and I have been thinking. Well...my sister, really. But I mean, it makes perfect sense, right? I'm glad you posted this =)

Clever! Very interesting.

And there I was thinking it was a Lord of the Flies rip off. (Jack is Roger, Saede is Simon, Locke is a decent version of Jack, Hurley is Piggy, so on).

I dunno. I can't wait to see!

woah I love this idea... *ponders quietly* and I can see it was a challenge to write this as there seems to be a lot of ideas getting worked out... But it was excellent.
by the way, what would we do without ?! I know i'd go insane.
keep up the great writing!

this is a really good story and it sounds like that is what is happening in the show...i know that might not have made much sense but i love the story so far and please continue soon.
; )

nice story, but not that original. this is the most common theory out there.