|Reviews for Circle|
| Frodo's sister 7/12/12 . chapter 1
This is a good story. It is also sad.
| Iorhaelwen 5/6/05 . chapter 1
Sad! Heart wrenching! *cries*
...Oh, uh, by the way, it's "gnawing", not "knawing". :)
| FrodoBaggins88 12/17/04 . chapter 1
*ponders* At first, I could see it as Sam struggling with himself, but then a the last few lines it sounded like Frodo. Hm... That's one I'll have to read again when I have more time to decide how to interpret it. :)
| Iorhael 12/16/04 . chapter 1
Oh, it's been so long since I last read your fics! Yes, of course I see it as Sam, about Frodo, but not clear who Sam's speaking to. Maybe Rosie? Yes, it must be her.
But Sam's grief is mine.
| Perhelediel 12/16/04 . chapter 1
wow. really moving. i like!
i believe that this is sam arguing with reality..."he has gone to give you happiness", much like "i tried to save the shire, and it has been saved. sometimes one has to give something they love up so others may enjoy it..."
hope i was right. this was really good. REALLY good.