 x19Narya90x 2009-02-14 . chapter 1Brilliant. Your writing style is so beautiful; it's fluid, and formal without being stilted. I especially love your last line - so powerful. Faramir is one of my favourite characters in the book, partly for the reasons you write about in this story; he's fearless, pure and honourable. A greater son born of lesser sires, indeed. |
 Dale 2008-04-15 . chapter 1 I love the way you turned Theoden's line to Saruman on it's head:
"A lesser son of great sires am I, but I do not need to lick YOUR fingers! Turn elsewhither! But I fear you voice has lost it's charm!" |
 Deandra 2008-04-14 . chapter 1Very powerful piece. Even though it is prose, it almost has a poetic feel to it. I can well imagine that these *were* Imrahil's thoughts and feelings on this occasion.
Well done!
- Deandra |
 lindahoyland 2007-05-07 . chapter 1Just heartrending and very well written.I love this glimpse of Imrahil's thoughts,it feels very true. |
 alena 2005-01-27 . chapter 1There is such a wonderful, wonderful rhythm to your words, carrying the heart onwards, it seems. It's incredibly moving. |
 scifiwasabi 2004-12-27 . chapter 1 I always love your stories, because you give so much insight into canon characters.
I love how you write also-descriptive when you need to be, but not overly so. Your writing is also clear and consice. :D |
 mahari 2004-12-25 . chapter 1 Bah, Losse. I know I don't review as much as I should, but this one compelled me to do so. Hauntingly beautiful.. the last line was exquisite. Well done! |
 Arahiril 2004-12-24 . chapter 1Very well-written, and a nice look at Imrahil, a character far too often overlooked. And I like the anger he feels towards Denethor - heck, I'd be mad as a hornet too. ^^ Excellent. |
 shie1dmaidenofrohan 2004-12-24 . chapter 1Beautiful story. Imrahil's definitely one of the lesser-appreciated characters, I think, and you described his feelings towards Faramir wonderfully. I especially liked the last line. |
 Raksha The Demon 2004-12-24 . chapter 1"Is it not enough that you put him from your heart, that you must now fling him before the Nazgû l’s feet like some carrion offering, brother mine?"
What a great line! And what a wonderful vignette! I can just feel Imrahil's anger burning like Faramir's fever.
I hope you'll write a longer piece about Faramir... |