I've read this story a number of times during the past few years, and I honestly can't remember if I've reviewed this before, although I'm more than willing to do it again.
This story is ultimately one of the best Percy-centric fics I've ever had the honor of reading. The entire series is absolutely exquisite, and every time I read it I start crying - especially in the second one, when Percy opens the box of Erec's memories. Gosh, there are so many things in here, small things, that have such a huge imapact- you have written exquisitely. The story itself was quite cathartic, fitting.

This is a great story.:)

I cried. So much. Damn you woman for wrenching my emotions so thoroughly! It was so beautiful! And it made so much sense... Erec was so real to me... and just so... Oh goodness. I made the mistake of reading it at school. I was a basket case. Crying all over the place, making my face all sticky and my eyes were puffy. My teacher actually pulled me aside and was like "...is everything okay? o_O" before the lecture started. BUT IT WAS SO PRETTY!!

I have another class in a few minutes, but I just wanted to know that I loved your Percy. Love. Loved, whatever. BEAUTIFUL work. Sheer joy to read (kinda)!

~ Melody

Wow! That was really good! I'm impressed with your description of emotion and development of plot!
Great work! I'm going to read the sequels now!

Wow.

You made me cry.

You made me cry. That was the saddest thing I have ever read but so beautiful. I just want to hug Percy and yay for Bill for being so good about it all. Such good writing

This was great! I had tears pouring down my face...

Absolutely incredible story-- literally THE best oneshot I've read on I love your perspective on Percy-- dear lord, it's so REALISTIC! Wonderful job.

Wow, I almost cried. No, I'll rephrase that! I cried. It's beautiful. I loved it. Kisses. XD

oh my.. wow thats an amazing ficcie. i cried from the dream, to the end of the fic. im serious, its amazing.. :) i usually dont review the fics that i read, but this was brilliant, and i felt like i should tell you what i think of it.

*sniffs* Now you went and ruined my reputation! This story was So sad! *wipes tears from eyes* Poor Percy! The 1st Harry books were good, but I loathe the 5th book! 2 reasons- Percy was a brat... And Sirius died! *fumes*

Such a beautiful story, it made me cry.

I really liked this story...or at least this part. I haven't read the other parts. But this was really insightfull. It made me want to cry when Erec died. You are a really gifted writer.

wow. i've got to say... this is probably the best story i've read. i always thought that percy was quite a brat- mostly in book 5- and he bugged the hell out of me.
I would have cried- but unfortunately, i'm not supposed to be on.
This is so good and i'm really glad I read this.

Sweet and tragic. One of the few stories that has made me cry. One of the best about Percy.