 swanhearttruly 11/17/03 . chapter 1That was purely awesome. I know u wrote this along time ago, but it was still good. It wasnt cheesy and lame (like all of mine are) it was somenthing just i dont know how i can explain it...anyhoo great fic... |
 FatCat 10/23/00 . chapter 1Mulder as a bad-guy-it never entered my mind. Good writing. |
 Ashley Adams 8/17/00 . chapter 1I loved it, I think that it shows that Mulder's more then just a porno loving guy, he has a heart too. Gosh that was great, if I can post your stories on my site then please e-mail me! |
 lalapine 8/7/00 . chapter 1 Intense. Good characterization of Mulder; he would definitely be very concerned if an old friend was having problems. I do object to saying that Mulder was as close to Cathy as he is to Scully; after everything he and Scully have been through, I find it hard to believe that he could be that close to a classmate at the Academy. One discrepancy: It says that Mulder and Cathy worked together after Scully's abduction, but then she asks him what he's done since the Academy, as though she hadn't seen him since then. Overall, good story. |
 Dramaphile 8/7/00 . chapter 1very well written. I liked it quite a bit, and I must say, the R rating is about right for the disturbing factor. It's nice to see someone write a good fic without cheesy romance or porno mulder scully love scenes. well done
-Drama |
 Batchickh 7/25/00 . chapter 1First, thanks for the review you sent me. It was greatly appreciated. Second, this was fantastic. Writing a rape scene is very difficult and you pulled it off well. It was very emotional, but the characters stayed true to who they are. Very well done! |
 Alexis Lane 7/19/00 . chapter 1 Mulder doing his job as a psychiatrist..novel idea ;) |
 T'Pau Silver 7/16/00 . chapter 1Very good. Not a cliche in site. I can't stand cliches. Refreshing to read something a little diferent. Very emotional. Worth reading. |
 Lioness Black 6/29/00 . chapter 1Ooh, I can't wait for a sequel...That was good. I love original characters, and you had the ones already there greatly in chraracter. Very Nice. I liked it alot. Lioness |
 Sonraie 6/23/00 . chapter 1 Great story. It was very touching. I could just picture Mulder being comforting and tender. |
 Patriot 6/21/00 . chapter 1 That was great! Reminds me a bit of some work of my own, or at least some ideas that have been rolling around in my head for awhile. Either way, awesome story. Bittersweet and powerful with a typically Mulder "White Knight-Underdog" ending. Well done! |
 Katvictory 6/10/00 . chapter 1A.H.-
I think this one is my favorite. Tense, great plotting. The pacing was A-1.
Kat |
 A.H.Smith 6/8/00 . chapter 1Ok, I'm very appreciative of everyone who has reviewed this thus far. Thank you very, very much. I know it seems intimidating at the begining, but it's pretty tame. I thank you all for your comments and encourage you to send others this way to leave their comments :-) (subtle hint) -thank you all again, -cheers and peace, A.H.Smith |
 Mel X Lady 6/8/00 . chapter 1Bravo!
You reviewed one of my stories, so I'm going to review one of yours:)
Very nice, not entirely graphic (thank goodness), but not enough to make you shake your head in shame.
I can't wait to read more of your fanfics:)
-Melissa
ps, thank you for reading mine and your kind words. |
 Leo 4/29/00 . chapter 1 It would read better if you change Mulder and Scully to your own characters' names-and give it an ending, instead of the Lady and the Tiger. Good tension.
Leo |