All four were good! You used free verse right? It's not my favorite style, but I really liked your poems. Good Job!

Beautiful description of the beckoning Frodo felt and the need to be healed.

He does try and you have captured his need to be redeemed.

Nice way to capture the feeling of the character.

Interesting poem. It brings the feel across well, but you could have used a little bit better wording. I like it a lot, though! :)

-lordoftheringsfanficreader