 TreeTopRoyalty 11/19/04 . chapter 1I get this. It's so...deep. |
 Timra 7/6/04 . chapter 1liked it. |
 Argentus 9 1/22/03 . chapter 1blank verse is pure freedom, don't you agree? the art of Shakespeare! another revealing moment in the saga of Sirius Black... appropriate word choices, good focus. i love it! if you'll allow me one comment... how is it that you don't like French? it's a wonderful language... and used frequently in HP as well, n'est pas? J.K.R. used to be a French teacher. hmm... what an odd coincidence that the previous reviewer also happens to go by "Argenteus"... |
 Argenteus Draco 10/15/02 . chapter 1I like. You should do more poetry. You have a real talent for it. Keep writing. |
 eclecticmum 1/22/02 . chapter 1Now I *know* my poetry's not up to snuff. The metaphors were beautifully descriptive of poor dear Sirius and the writing gave me shivers. Brava. |
 Twinnie 12/28/01 . chapter 1Waw, this is great ! I love the symbolism (the lexical field of the water, the one of darkness, etc) Gah, it's so good, that I've passed in the literature-student-who-analizes-every-good-text-she-comes-across mode, something that barely happens when I'm reading fanfics... You must have spent some time on this poem, and the result is quite great ! Congratulations =) |
 Angel Child 11/30/01 . chapter 1 Omigosh! That was so touching - u describe Sirius in the way I do, which I could never find the words for. JK, you've got some talent!
Siriusly and Most Ridkulusly
Angel |
 Ly3 9/30/01 . chapter 1loss of words... |
 Crete 9/16/01 . chapter 1 This is excellent! write more poetry, it really gives you a clear picture, and i usually dont like free verse, but that was very good! |
 gumdrop 6/20/01 . chapter 1This is really good, i like it a lot. You're very talented. |
 Lavender 3/9/01 . chapter 1 You're a really good poet |
 Orion Black 3/8/01 . chapter 1 *smiles broadly* that's my dad! |
 Twilight and Silence 3/8/01 . chapter 1That was good... a few of the lines were a bit awkward, for instance, "But he and his friends fight the waves", but on the whole, excellent. |
 Crazy Poet 3/8/01 . chapter 1 Oh, that gives me chills! Spectacular really. It really painted a picture, you know? Wow, you really have talent, keep up the great poetry! |
 Midnightzstorm and Kedavra 3/8/01 . chapter 1OOO, I really liked this! ~Daydreamer |