 Pistachio Rules 8/25/11 . chapter 1A very interesting fiction! |
 Don'tCry 1/6/06 . chapter 1IT is an interesting take on luna, who is usually portrayed as a vibrant character, but the fact that her vivaciousness is all an act is still viable. very beautifully written, it has a certain rhythm to it which resembels poetry. |
 Bagge 10/13/05 . chapter 1Oh dear! Poor Luna. She is lonly, but does not even feel enough to feel bad about it. And this boy. Malfoy maybe, probably? In the same situation. Kissing to escape neutrality. Sad but beautiful. I can't say I believe her to be that empty, but who can really say what hides behind those unblinking eyes? |
 BellonaBellatrix 8/8/05 . chapter 1Very nice...because I do see Luna as a detached character to a point and you captured that very, very well. She cares about others more than herself at times, I think. And she can, through her mind and her own independence, be separated from the whole process of living. Well done! I enjoyed this! |
 Dreaming One 6/26/05 . chapter 1A few bits that need correcting for grammar or whatever:
"It was own little play, with no audience."
"Maybe he was in love with someone else, someone she couldn’t have, or maybe he was just incapable of love."
Whoa, it must have been some mood! ;) I get those moods all the time, so I understand. Creepily enough, your Luna characterization reminded me chillingly of myself. A lot of people who don't know me well think I'm crazy, but really I'm just abstract and detached. I'm often quite happy, but the detachedness doesn't ever really go away. I can definitely see Luna being like that due to trauma in her past. *nods* Good characterization.
I still don't know what I think of this ship. I think Luna would go better with Harry, because his passion would provide some balance for her tendency to dwell on the cerebral, but this still works.
Why was her common room red rather than blue?
Keep Writing!
May |
 vegiegurl 6/23/05 . chapter 1So nice. It's just sad and beautiful. |
 Starred Signature 4/16/05 . chapter 1Great job! I love it. |
 Phoenix Fairy 4/9/05 . chapter 1I like it. Good one. |
 Snozzle 3/24/05 . chapter 1Aw. So sweet and sad.. |
 winky-wink 2/27/05 . chapter 1i think that was a very pretty story. i liked the way you wrote it. it kinda made me ache for more afterwards. and i like how you didn't make it obvious who the guy she was kissing was. good job! |
 Chocolatebrowneyes 2/20/05 . chapter 1cool pairing of Luna and Draco I liked this
Choco |
 Silver to Crimson 2/14/05 . chapter 1Another interesting one-shot. I actually just read through your list of stories and came to realise that I've read most of them without even noticing. Awesome work! |
 Nox Periculum 2/10/05 . chapter 1Great just more chapters. Its a good beginning continue please |
 PinkTribeChick 2/10/05 . chapter 1Wonderful little piece! A nice look into the darker side of Luna! Keep up the great work! 8D |
 Malakhim 2/10/05 . chapter 1 Yes, suspicions confirmed: you are definitely an amazingly talented writer. I love the way you use language; it feels so fresh and new and original but you never loose the thread of your story or the characters. |