 PheobeColelovers 7/7/05 . chapter 3stumbled on this fanfic and am completely in love with it. |
 Lyn Vo 12/9/04 . chapter 3Such a great story. Thank you very much Michelle for writing it. |
 Moon Destiny 7/5/04 . chapter 1Sad but good. It was sort of hopeful, to see Cole's demon self love a little. I was surprised when you write Phoebe died in a car accident but I guess that had to be there to make the story fit. Anyways, good job. |
 Maria Kairay 2/12/03 . chapter 1SAD! SAD! SO SAD! BUT PLEASE, KEEP WRITING LIKE THIS! |
 Phoebe Halliwell4 3/7/02 . chapter 1Sad. But good. |
 Jackie 11/22/01 . chapter 1 This is so sad - you write such great stories but they all have a certain pain to them. Write a "happy" Phoebe & Cole story! |
 Author ClowReed 6/27/01 . chapter 1 I read the sequal to this fic and they are both very good. PLEASE CONTINUE! PLEASE CONTINUE Belthazar's Story! |
 Maggie 4/20/01 . chapter 1 You made me cry! Oh, man, this was so sad. I feel so bad for Cole. The human part of him, not really the demon. This was really good. |
 Monica Faour 3/18/01 . chapter 1 wow!...very good!...sad but good!...once again WOW! |
 Piper Mary Cherry Milano1 3/11/01 . chapter 1SOOO GOOD! (drip, drip) |
 Jessica28 3/11/01 . chapter 1oh my! |
 Soulfire Stories 3/10/01 . chapter 1aaaaaaaaaaaaawwwwwwww i loved the story. |
 Trinity Day 3/10/01 . chapter 1Tragic and dark, but very, very good. |