Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: A Gryffindor After All
Blue Flyhight
2008-05-06 . chapter 1
Wow this is brilliant! Peter doesn't get enough love... even from JKR. I can't see Peter as starting out evil, and this explains his motivations perfectly. I've only found one other good Peter story. So glad I found this.
Ginny is awsome
2007-08-03 . chapter 1
when i read harry potter and the promise ring i never even thought why would he do save ginny & i never thought about why he betrayed james and lily (i thought that lily was in griffendor ) but thats a good idea!
q.thews
2005-12-26 . chapter 1
I'm very interested in learning why oh why Wormtail did what he did even in 1981 (and in Promise Ring)
But i'm quite doubtful that he was treated so badly by the other Marauders (think about Remus and his condition and Sirius and his relationship with his family), we need to found what was good in him that drove the four of them to become The Marauders.
Ok, that said i liked this, just one thing he must be a very fast thinker to think all of this in so few minutes :-)
Bye
x se
2005-07-24 . chapter 1
Very nice, very nice. A sequel to OotP? Sounds interesting.

Anyway, I liked this story a lot, though personally, I think back in Hogwarts, Wormtail was actually a lot mroe than the "yes-man" as you and most of the characters have put it. The Marauders were friedns and equals in thier Hogwarts years, even if some were better in more ways than others.

Anyway, thanks for the great read. I'll keep a lookout for your next work.
GinnyDragon54
2005-03-06 . chapter 1
Wow... I'm not normally a fan of PeterFics, but... WOW! That was good. I almost feel sorry for him now... almost...
Love From,
Stephie-Chan
WindMadeSolid
2005-02-11 . chapter 1
Great plot idea, I enjoyed reading it! I also really like the song you wove into the story, very fitting.
rankokun alpha
2005-02-11 . chapter 1
i loved it i wish you would continue on after the promise ring! i wait for it with bated breath and keep re-reading it because it is so good!
JeanieBeanie33
2005-02-11 . chapter 1
I liked, no, loved it. This was great! Very reflective, makes you think about Peter. I can't wait until you write that yet-to-be named fic.
Return to Top