Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Caught Between the Light and Dark - Page 1 of 10
andaere
2009-09-02 . chapter 15
Wow, this is an amazing story! I would be smiling at the hobbit fluff one moment, tense with suspense the next, and rooting on the characters another moment. What I'm trying to say is that this story really evoked my emotions (and that it is very multi-genred). You write in character and extremely well. I didn't spot one grammatical or spelling error! :)

This also had all of the hobbit love and angst that I just can't live without. I also loved the resourcefulness of all of the characters, especially Frodo and Merry. Overall, a wonderful, enjoyable story! (I gotta admit, though, my pulse is still racing. xD)
Robin Gurl
2009-05-28 . chapter 15
wow very impressed how you still manage to hurt!pippin and comfort him while at the same time hurting Frodo. and in this fic, Merry to. *her mind explodes* :D
Robin Gurl
2009-05-28 . chapter 9
I was wondering if giving Pippin that drug was a good idea. *rolls eyes* its like me with out my concerta. I swear Pip has a middle earth version of ADHD. :P

Great capture! And Poor Merry. I hope he's alright.
AspenJules
2006-04-11 . chapter 12
I don't think I've reviewed this story yet, mostly because it's been the middle of the night when I've been reading it. May I say - not necessarily a good story to read in the middle of the night? LOL

However, I came out of lurking mode in this chapter because I simply *had* to say I love your Boromir. His "Goodbye, my friend. May we meet again in a better place" brought a lump to my throat. Kind of a nice parallel to his death at Parth Galen for Merry and Pippin, but this time he was offering his life for the ringbearer. Makes his ultimate defeat by the ring even more bittersweet.

I also liked the end of Ch. 11, with the last rays of the sun staining the warg's fangs red. Great description!
Anawey
2006-03-04 . chapter 15
YAY! Holy Jeeze, that thing with the poisoned blade is freaking creepy. Man I am so glad you didn't decide to have Frodo get cut by that sword cause then they'd have to beat the clock back to Rivendel and that would be quite the attention grabber. This story rocks.
Time and Fate
2005-12-16 . chapter 15
well, that was kool
Cindy
2005-11-13 . chapter 15
I enjoyed your story very much. Will you be writing a sequel, continuing to follow the fellowship east?? I am particularly glad that you are not portraying Boromir as evil; he was not. Thanks for the reading pleasure!
:-)
lindahoyland
2005-11-01 . chapter 15
Thank you for an enjoyable story, I loved the sweet Hobbit moments in this chapter and to see Frodo doing the great deeds he is capable of.
Azaelia
2005-10-31 . chapter 15
What a nice Halloween present for me to log on and find that you had updated this story just a few days ago!

I love the ending, with Frodo, weary but determined leading on. It's a great note on which to end this adventure. Excellent, suspenseful work as always!! Amazing what one sentence of dialogue will do in terms of inspiration. I always found "I will crush him" to be a bit odd-sounding, but you have provided a backstory that makes perfect sense. :)

I eagerly await the next tale!

~Azaelia
Ainu Laire
2005-10-30 . chapter 15
Finally had a chance to read this (school has been keeping me extremely busy), and I absolutely loved it!

"Peregrin, stop jumping up and down on those rocks—the Nazgûl is more to the left, anyway."

LOL! Awesome line XD That's absolutely hilarious, and something I can completely see Gandalf saying.

Aww, that whole scene with Merry and Pippin was cute. And Pippin snuggling against Aragorn!! AW! *dies from the cuteness*

... and the cuteness dies. Figures there would be something else around :P I loved that battle scene. Hehehe, the warg dragged Aragorn through the air... *giggles* Sorry, it's a bit late... and I'm a bit hyper =D

I like your Legolas. It's like the book-Legolas. His eyes twinkle. I like that a lot.

Oh man, I do love these Fellowship stories! Just so awesome!
lovethosehobbits
2005-10-27 . chapter 15
Well done, indeed. I loved this fic almost as much as all of your others. great job...
lovethosehobbits
2005-10-27 . chapter 14
Goody, goody goody! Can't wait for more. Nasty Ringwraith lets fire up the torches and take care of it's dirty, tattered clothing only to have it come and fight another day. Go Frodo, my beloved and brave hobbit!
darklink231
2005-10-23 . chapter 15
i like how you ended it. the hobbits are all messed up, and legolas is as hot as ever! lol very nice! bill freaked out because of the warg... thats kind of what happened at my horse show yesterday... but anyway great job!
smalldiver
2005-10-22 . chapter 15
Brilliant ending - and I love how you got the inspiration for this story. I did get the vibe that there was a 'thing' between Gandalf and the Witch King - the Nazgul seemed intent on destroying Gandalf, and this explains why quite well!
Frodo Silverlune
2005-10-21 . chapter 15
that's the end? aww, but i guess it did have to end there. GO FRODO! excellent story. *sigh* i wish i didn't have to go clean now.
Return to Top